Proposal: Another Price Proposal

[WreckingCrew]

What about Darling, Kuokkanen, Elyniuk and a 1st?

What about Price, Scherbak, Evans, and a 1st?

 

[ChaoticOrange]

I'd do it for Darling and Necas alone. Bean/Kruger have no value, the 1st is just vanilla.

Habs fans:

‘Noah Juulsen and Charlie Lindgren is a very fair price for RNH’

Also Habs fans:

‘A defence prospect significantly better than Juulsen has no value’

 

[Mrb1p]

Habs fans:

‘Noah Juulsen and Charlie Lindgren is a very fair price for RNH’

Also Habs fans:

‘A defence prospect significantly better than Juulsen has no value’

Bean is significantly better than a player that has had more success at a better level ? Amazing.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Bean is significantly better than a player that has had more success at a better level ? Amazing.

Caught ya before your ninja edit realized they weren’t drafted the same year did we?

Juulsen is 21. Almost two full years older than Bean. Of course he’s playing a better level of hockey.

 

[Mrb1p]

Caught ya before your ninja edit realized they weren’t drafted the same year did we?

Juulsen is 21. Almost two full years older than Bean. Of course he’s playing a better level of hockey.

Regardless, Bean isn't going to amount to anything, you can quote me on that in five years.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Regardless, Bean isn't going to amount to anything, you can quote me on that in five years.

Your no doubt incredibly learned opinion of his upside doesn’t have any bearing on his value whatsoever.

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

Not against the idea of Price to Carolina for Darling++. But that deal absolutely does not include Martin Necas. Zero chance.

ya man hes obv another Mcdavid prospect overrated!

 

[Pia8988]

ya man hes obv another Mcdavid prospect overrated!

Just Price who is overrated.

 

[connormcmuffin]

Patches (big ''tough'' winner), Galchenyuk ("miscast C") and Price, Montreal has the pieces to exploit Carolina's genius owner. They should target Hanifin.

 

[72hockey guy]

id say Price straight up for Darling is a better base if carolina wants to take on 5 years more and 70M owed Price

talent wise

Price>>>Darling

but contract wise

Darling>>>> Price

montreal fans would say playing ability matters more
carolina fans would say playing ability isnt worth 70M more

so it depends on where you stand on the pay for play spectrum

 

[theghost1]

Habs fans:

‘Noah Juulsen and Charlie Lindgren is a very fair price for RNH’

Also Habs fans:

‘A defence prospect significantly better than Juulsen has no value’

RNH is terrible would help Montreal 0%.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

RNH is terrible would help Montreal 0%.

RNH >> Drouin

 

[72hockey guy]

RNH is terrible would help Montreal 0%.

i dont know about that, as long as he's used correctly at 2 C, he'd be an improvement. marginal maybe but an improvement nonetheless

 

[72hockey guy]

RNH >> Drouin

too soon to say, and given the parameters of the of the individual teams theyd be joining I think such a trade favors the oilers since drouin is cheaper and signed longer and roster construction wise easier to accommodate, though as center insurance, that is mitigated somewhat

it depends on personal preference

 

[Chan790]

Patches (big ''tough'' winner), Galchenyuk ("miscast C") and Price, Montreal has the pieces to exploit Carolina's genius owner. They should target Hanifin.

Carolina's "genius owner" made his billions in auto loans for subprime borrowers...he's both smart and sleazy enough to take MB for a ride and make it seem like a favor.

Montreal will end up paying us to take Price for Darling and the rights to some guy playing 4th line minutes in Liiga.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

too soon to say, and given the parameters of the of the individual teams theyd be joining I think such a trade favors the oilers since drouin is cheaper and signed longer and roster construction wise easier to accommodate, though as center insurance, that is mitigated somewhat

it depends on personal preference

Drouin is cheaper because he’s not as good. RNH is just flat out better - more versatile, a better scorer, better defensively, just... better.

He’s also showing he can be damned effective on the wing.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

How on earth does this make sense to you, op? Carolina is not going to give up their first and two of their best prospects just to dump Darling all the while taking on the worst contract in the league in Price and another bad one in Shaw. Goalies don’t have that kind of value even on fair contracts.

 

[Flamesfan62]

Is he doing good in your opinion?

He’s doing fairly well yes, and the fact that he’s 19...

 

[GoldiFox]

I'd do it for Darling and Necas alone. Bean/Kruger have no value, the 1st is just vanilla.

He's busting pretty hard, but thats my opinion, no need to derail.

Have any other bad Jake Bean hot takes? He put up 5A last night and is now leading the WHL Playoffs in D points/game. Better than Clague, Foote, Valimaki, Jokiharju, etc. Seems to be helping.

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

Price is Montreal's franchise goalie. I doubt he gets moved.

 

[danyhabsfan]

RNH >> Drouin

I have nothing against RNH but Id keep Drouin.

That would be a lateral move at best.

Also Drouin had 13 pts in his last 14 games which leads me to believe he can do better next season.

 

[GoldiFox]

Regardless, Bean isn't going to amount to anything, you can quote me on that in five years.

He's busting pretty hard, but thats my opinion, no need to derail.

Hey Bean is busting out the points, leading Defensemen in the WHL Playoffs (14P in 8GP) now after a 1st Star, 3A night. You have any other bad scouting opinions about him we should hear? Want to elaborate?

 

[Mrb1p]

Hey Bean is busting out the points, leading Defensemen in the WHL Playoffs (14P in 8GP) now after a 1st Star, 3A night. You have any other bad scouting opinions about him we should hear? Want to elaborate?

No, i already made my bold claim, i dont care about what you think about him. Head over to the prospect board if you want to discuss him, ill be glad to.

 

[Captain Mountain]

Habs fans:

‘Noah Juulsen and Charlie Lindgren is a very fair price for RNH’

Also Habs fans:

‘A defence prospect significantly better than Juulsen has no value’

I love it when people assume all fans have the same views.

 

[Hostile Offer]

id say Price straight up for Darling is a better base if carolina wants to take on 5 years more and 70M owed Price

talent wise

Price>>>Darling

but contract wise

Darling>>>> Price

montreal fans would say playing ability matters more
carolina fans would say playing ability isnt worth 70M more

so it depends on where you stand on the pay for play spectrum

Both had a remarkably bad year compared to their previous ones so it's hard to say what's their actual level going forward but... whether you have someone who was considered as the undisputed best goalie in the world not too long ago or you have someone who used to be a great backup goalie until he was absolutely crushed at his first starter job, I know which one I would take no matter what kinda contracts they have (and they are both really bad). One is proven, one is very much not. If you're a contender, you should have a goalie you can rely on.