Yeah apparently gelinas looked good. We may actually have a solid defense corps. Brodin, scandy, spurg, Dumba, olofsson, folin, gelinas. Lot of young guys that could be here a while.
Phillips on the other hand is a player that is stuck in prospect limbo a bit at this point. Being a former first round pick a huge point producer in his juniors career, maybe Phillips wont crack an NHL roster unless he prove capable of playing bottom six minutes?
Keranen actually showed some frustration and played a bit of physically punishing hockey which was an interest development and reinforced a bit what we heard on him. Keranen maybe had bad day but certainly the word for Michael Russo earlier today that he was open to playing for the 'Baby Wild' gives him a more realistic shot to play in North America this fall.
The most impressive in this group in my opinion was 2013 2nd round selection Gustav Olofsson who used is big frame to eliminate opponents opportunity and separate them from the puck often
The defenseman invitee group included Alex Gudbranson who is the brother of Florida top prospect Eric who was selected 3rd overall in 2010. Alex is 19 years old and has gon undrafted to this point. Hunter Warner is an Eden Prairie kid who has been playing for Waterloo of the USHL. Warner was looking to make a name for himself today lining up opponents and delivering punishing body checks including a center ice hit on Bartschy that caused hum to miss a shift or two shaking the cobwebs out.
I really don't see Phillips doing a heck of a lot. Pieces of that trade, outside Coyle, didn't amount to much. Phillips, I don't see him playing in the NHL. Setoguchi turned into a few games from Matt Moulson. Basically Burns for Coyle.
I really don't see Phillips doing a heck of a lot. Pieces of that trade, outside Coyle, didn't amount to much. Phillips, I don't see him playing in the NHL. Setoguchi turned into a few games from Matt Moulson. Basically Burns for Coyle.
Ya Coyle was the biggest factor in that trade.
Plus, as you say, anything Phillips might provide at the NHL level would now be considered a bonus. I'll take that haul all day considering GMCF only parted with one year of Brent Burns -- before he was sure to ditch in favor of more money and a better short-term solution via free agency. The Moulson move was a solid gamble at the time, regardless of how the playoffs turned out.
Disagree! The kid had a Wild tattoo. I honstly think he'd have given us a more than fair shot at re-signing him to the same deal or better than he gave San Jose.
I do agree with the Moulson deal. It was a fair deal for a guy who had scored 30+ goals the last 2 seasons. He just didn't work that well here, unfortunately.
As for Phillips, Jarick, I think he's got room to grow. Don't get me wrong, I was actually chanting "Saad" and "Rattie" that draft, but Phillips was not a bad conciliation prize. That said, I was also chanting, and quote my friends on this, "Trouba" and "Forsberg" over their "Dumba" that day. So who knows?
Jesus what if we would have gone for Saad though...
IIRC Saad slid pretty bad due to a perceived lack of worth ethic. Also I think Saad went to a perfect situation in Chicago, but yeah it be nice to have him now.
I'll take that haul all day considering GMCF only parted with one year of Brent Burns -- before he was sure to ditch in favor of more money and a better short-term solution via free agency.
The Moulson move was a solid gamble at the time, regardless of how the playoffs turned out.
We don't know the terms for what Burns wanted. If we only got Coyle back for Burns, that is a terrible trade on Minnesota's end. We traded a highly mobile, physical defenseman that had top 3 potential (and still does) for a 3rd line grinder. That's like trading Brodin for Brandon Saad. I don't think anyone would do that trade. I was all for the trade (and still partly am, provided that Phillips develops but given Minnesota's latest track record, that looks kind of doubtful) but looking back, it's one of those trades that you wake up the next morning and go, what the hell did I do?
Moulson was fine - it wasn't a bad trade. Wasn't a great trade. But man Buffalo sure wrecked it. There are winners. And then were winners. And Buffalo won that trade by and far.
We don't know the terms for what Burns wanted. If we only got Coyle back for Burns, that is a terrible trade on Minnesota's end. We traded a highly mobile, physical defenseman that had top 3 potential (and still does) for a 3rd line grinder. That's like trading Brodin for Brandon Saad. I don't think anyone would do that trade. I was all for the trade (and still partly am, provided that Phillips develops but given Minnesota's latest track record, that looks kind of doubtful) but looking back, it's one of those trades that you wake up the next morning and go, what the hell did
We got a couple years of Seto (which allowed a prospect to develop in the ahl instead of the NHL) and Seto helped us get Moulson who helped us make the playoffs this year. Most importantly Burns salary may have prevented us from signing Praise and Suter which cannot be overlooked...