Do we still have all our top players? check
Do we still have all our top prospects? check
Did we add a #2 C which we have not had in 2 years? check
Did we add a vet RH Dman that we wanted? check
Did we add a backup goalie? check
Did we avoid overpaying a likely 4th liner in Hartman? check
Did we upgrade in Head, PK and PP coaching? check
....all for the cost of a 5th, 2nd(that we re-couped), a 3rd, and cap space. And only 1 player added is here long term. Fletch has bridged the gap from the older core to the next.
Sure, we still have our top players, but personally I thought now was the time to go out and add to the top of the core with a real impact player. We didn't do that. Instead, we went Hayes, Braun, & Niskanen.
We still have all of our top prospects, for which I'm thankful, but we added 2 veteran dmen, both of whom are on the decline, who are going to take away playing time from our young defensemen, and I question whether it's going to be a net benefit in the end. I'd also had rather spent that money / assets on PK, but then my head is clearly in a different place than most others.
We added a 2C on a contract I'm not ok with.
We didn't add a back-up goalie. We simply re-signed Elliott. I'm "okay" with that, and frankly think it makes more sense than throwing 3M AAV at Talbot for him to stay here, but that feeds into the pattern of questionable moves vis-a-vis the Talbot / Stolarz swap.
We added vet RH D, but was anyone really clamoring for Niskanen or Braun?
Once again, the Hartman deal feeds into the patters of questionable moves. It would have been better for Fletch to just take straight picks for Simmer rather than seek a roster player that we just dumped off to an oft-injured soon-to-be UFA 4th liner.
AV was not my first choice. I want Therrien nowhere near the team. Yeo just got humiliated.
It is crazy how dire some think things are. I wanted all those things to happen , so far, so good.
Hayes deal is def not perfect, but those are some SOLID moves
It's not that it's dire. They are probably an improved team next year and comfortably make the playoffs. It's that there's a bad feeling that we're making the wrong mid & longterm moves. That we're building a team to win one playoff round instead of four.
[MOD]