So this topic is near and dear to my heart. Like the Golden Retriever of music discussions for me. Ask any classic rock fan and you'll get different responses. The attached video goes over the list and hits on most of the guys mentioned even if it doesn't get all of them and doesn't order them in a consensus fashion beyond maybe number 1.
I went back and rethought what a "Mount Rushmore" would encapsulate. To me, it's guys who built the foundation for where we are today. You probably don't go back and add FDR JFK or Reagan to Mt. Rushmore even if you saw them as giants. Accordingly, to me I'll suggest that my Mount Rushmore is different than my favorites or the guys I think were/are the best. Props to
@LeedsMonster for the topic. I expect others to have their own view of the Mt. Rushmore definition and even if they agree with me on that, I expect their inclusions to be different.
My Mt. Rushmore would be:
Robert Johnson
Chuck Berry
Jimi Hendrix
Les Paul
I don't include great players from the recent era since to a man or woman, they are all judged against Hendrix to me. For Mt. Rushmore purposes I'll include him as the embodiment of modern rock guitar. I agree that Berry's 1950s work influenced and an argument can be made that he was at least indirectly responsible, on some level, for most riff-based classic rock that came out after 1963. Buddy Holly would also be part of that discussion. Robert Johnson, to me, invented modern rock and roll in 1936. Think about that, 1936. Of course, Memphis Minnie wrote When the Levee Breaks in 1929, but I digress. Finally, as great as any number of players are, there are two iconic guitars that stand above the rest for most people. The Fender Strat, and the Gibson Les Paul. Paul is often credited creating the modern solid body guitar and also adding things like effects pedals and multi-tracking. To me, he deserves to be on the Mt. Rushmore.
The funny thing is while I recognize the genius of these men, I rarely listen to them. Once in a blue moon I'll have my history of rock discussion with one of my sons' friends and play Crossroads Blues but unless Hendrix is in a streaming music feed I'm not choosing to listen to him. I haven't chosen to listen to Berry or Paul in I can't even recall.
My favorites are inextricably linked with the songs they perform in and would be an entirely different list.