Alfredsson was the living, breathing heart of that team. He took it on his back and carried it through four rounds. He won the Buffalo series for us and was one of the few players on the team that actually showed up versus Anaheim, and could very well have won the Conn Smythe. He did everything for us, from scoring to passing to backchecking to agitating the other team. We also had a prime Heatley, decent depth at forward and a bunch of 20+ point defencemen.
If you're going to point to Detroit, Alfie isn't the key there he's another player and he's been doing well for them. Detroit is fighting for the division lead and we are not.
The fact is, we lost a ton of experience and two-way play when Gonchar, Alfredsson and Silfverberg left in the same season. Replacing Gonchar with Corvo is a downgrade. Replacing Alfredsson's two-way play (even aging) with the invisible MacArthur is a downgrade. Replacing Silf with Ryan is even, edge to us offensively but at best neutral defensively. You want to know why we're allowing so many early goals against? The guys we have now at forward aren't quick to fold back or position themselves or fight for the puck. The Spezza line just waits for the puck to get to them. The Turris line is great, Turris does a lot of the work. The other two lines are offence deficient but decent enough. Our "D" is a bit of a mess. Karlsson is really the only one that can move the puck with elegance and efficiency; Phillips is crap, Methot is decent but lacks offensive instincts. Gryba, Cowen are offensive black holes.
So all this being said, what is Murray going to do? He could trade Neil (though he probably has a NTC like everyone else on the team) but he won't because he's too sentimental and afraid of a shake-up like that. So he trades a Zack Smith or Greening? That might send a message to the team...but the message that needs to be sent is from MacLean; he needs to sit Neil or someone down for a game or they need to get less ice time. If a player is selfish or lazy on the ice and gets more ice time it spreads through the team, bad habits develop and then you enter a funk.
MacLean needs to earn his pay and fix this before the team falls too behind in the wild card race.