I am not a huge fan of starting Hutch tonight coming off an OT Loss to NYR, we need to avoid back to back losses as best we can. On the flip side, I also understand the logic of not leaving Hutch out to dry Tmw. I remember a B2B (Boston and Pitt) a couple years back right before Babs got sacked. He played Freddy game 1 because he always loved to leave his backup tendy out to dry on the second half of the B2B. We lost to Boston in the first leg of the B2B, and then got our eyes pumped shut by a rested Pitt team. We dress Kaskisao against Pitt, and completely shattered his confidence.
We may need our goalie to steal us one Tmw, and Soupy is realistically our only hope of doing that for us. And from a confidence standpoint, I think he has proven himself the most to the fanbase, and can handle a potentially bad loss.
All that said, I'd still go with Soupy tonight if it were me. SJ is not just going to lay down for us. There are a 5 players from Ontario in their lineup that will be playing in front of family for the first time in god knows how long, and Barabanov + Reimer "revenge" game narratives. It's not that I think Hutch can't get the job done, and if we lose it likely wont be his fault, but they already have incentives to win. dressing our 3rd stringer when we can dress our 1A is just 1 other thing for them to add to the bulletin board. Not to mention they are 3-0-0. Which of course means nothing in the long term, but right now each of those players are playing like they have 10lb cocks.
Leafs will have to be ready for them. I'm generally an optimistic Leaf fan, but unfortunately I've seen these let down games far far too often with this group. I really hope they go out there and f***ing demand the ice