This is personal taste kind of thing. We all have our own likes and dislikes..so, not a critique of your preferences.
I like Simmer's zaniness..it is refreshing and I believe that he is far sharper than we give him credit for. He drops nuggets that can go un-noticed, but are sharp. So, I like him on there and 5 days a week. Plus the odd appearance on the pre-game show.
My beef is; with Whity gone, with Jason York gone. There is no ex pro (hockey, or football, or other) on there. It is guys with zero sports history..I know, you can be just as knowledgeable...but, you do not have insight, or inside stories.
you could even mix and match. Get Methot on there with an ex CFLr. Or an ex elite-athlete, baseball, soccer, baseball, golf...etc. Find someone in the city. Get a Jeff Avery to cohost with Methot. Give them a good producer/director who can guide the show and let them be.
I have two left feet, let me be upfront. I played rec hockey only. And so, I laugh at the 6 million posts on here of guys who talk the minutia of the game. I trip over my own feet avoiding a large number of threads that discuss specifics and I will only post general comments and often enough on non detailed subjects (this as an example). I find that the TSN1200 on air people are the just like here. Guys who probably cannot skate, but see themselves as hockey savants and can coach a power-play better than pro coaches..It becomes silly....listen to Methot's explanation on fighting and the NY rangers stuff from a few years ago,..and then see the babble on here...silly
New blood, new knowledgeable blood. New blood that can give insight. I would feel so much better if I ever saw the TSN1200 hosts play a pickup hockey game. T least I would know they can skate.