I really don't think he's been bad defensively this year. In a small sample, his CF%rel is great and his xGA/60 is only behind Skjei and Skjei's primary partner (McQuaid).
I'm way more disappointed that our PP has been meh and he isn't driving offense.
This is word for word the same story as last year. I'm beginning to theorize that this is the player Shattenkirk is.
The power play was pretty great to start the season last year when he was running it, but after his injury got worse he started struggling a lot more.
He hasn't looked good running it so far this year yet. I do think the injury really screwed with him and we forget it was something he suffered in training camp last year so he hasn't really been healthy and 100% for his entire time with the Rangers.
His greatest value is as a PP QB and he's basically been a cheat code at that for his whole career so realistically when he gets back into the swing of things I think we'll see that part of his game take off.