Speculation: TDL (02/24) Discussion

[STL Shark]

Amazing how someone can be so upset when we just got a first round pick for a 4th liner and a potential 2nd (definite 3rd) for a 42 year old who has 10 goals and we acquired for free this season.

What does Aaron Dell being on this roster have to do with the Goodrow deal? I'm flabbergasted by how insane of a connection you are trying to make here... I literally said that the Goodrow return was great in another post. Still has nothing to do with why you can't do more by moving another asset whose value will never be higher (i.e. Dell).

 

[hohosaregood]

I'm guessing we trade the COL 2nd back to get a 4th. PHI 3rd trade back can maybe get another 4th. SJ 5th trade back to get two 6ths? And trade PITT and WSH 7th for a 6th

 

[Friday]

I'm guessing we trade the COL 2nd back to get a 4th. PHI 3rd trade back can maybe get another 4th. SJ 5th trade back to get two 6ths? And trade PITT and WSH 7th for a 6th

Or trade both the 2020 2nds to move the 2020 TB 1st from 26th to 23rd haha

 

[themelkman]

I think we should root for Pens. Second next year is better than changing a third next year to a third this year

 

[Coily]

Of course, Kurz is on twitter complaining about Goodrow lol

 

[weastern bias]

Fire DW

Agreed

That video came out 5 years ago, how Doug hasn't managed to get rid of all parties involved by this point is beyond me

 

[TheWayToRefJose]

Assuming we get a first for Goodrow, what does our pick breakdown look like this year?

TBL 1st
SJ 2nd, COL 2nd
Phi 3rd
SJ 5th, OTT 5th
Pitt 7th, Wash 7th

 

[Pavelski2112]

Of course, Kurz is on twitter complaining about Goodrow lol

Holy shit really? The Sharks absolutely fleece Tampa and Kurz is complaining? I'm absolutely convinced he doesn't watch hockey.

 

[DG93]

The dentist doing work today! Good haul.

 

[OffSydes]

Holy shit really? The Sharks absolutely fleece Tampa and Kurz is complaining? I'm absolutely convinced he doesn't watch hockey.

His entire argument is that a contending team needs cheap depth.

 

[Pavelski2112]

His entire argument is that a contending team needs cheap depth.

Yes...and we're not a contender. What's his point?

 

[themelkman]

Kurz really thinks keeping Goodrow and Melker makes more sense than getting a top sixer and replacing the bottom six

 

[Sharksrule04]

What does Aaron Dell being on this roster have to do with the Goodrow deal? I'm flabbergasted by how insane of a connection you are trying to make here... I literally said that the Goodrow return was great in another post. Still has nothing to do with why you can't do more by moving another asset whose value will never be higher (i.e. Dell).

It's the tone of your posts. Crapping on the person that Jumbo is, whining about not getting even a 7th for Dell (Maybe DW is going to re-sign him/maybe there weren't any offers?). Jumbo is incredibly loyal to the Sharks, San Jose and the franchise that has been home to him for a long time. You thinking less of a 42 year old, while not even knowing the full details of the discussions that occurred is just laughable to me. It's just a level of negativity I can't comprehend on a day that was one of the few bright spots of the season.

 

[Coily]

Holy shit really? The Sharks absolutely fleece Tampa and Kurz is complaining? I'm absolutely convinced he doesn't watch hockey.

He said it's a good return, but that the Sharks have no forward depth next year and that Goodrow was a great PK'er.

 

[Lebanezer]

Of course, Kurz is on twitter complaining about Goodrow lol

I lol'ed quite hard at his tweets. Especially when he said good depth players don't grow on trees.

 

[Levie]

His entire argument is that a contending team needs cheap depth.

Which is why Tampa traded for him...

 

[Tw1ster]

His entire argument is that a contending team needs cheap depth.

He’s a damned fool if he is hinting at all that the Sharks shouldn’t have made this trade

 

[Jwec]

I lol'ed quite hard at his tweets. Especially when he said good depth players don't grow on trees.

Yeah. Because good depth players exactly grow on trees compared to 1st round picks and top 6 players.

 

[WSS11]

Of course, Kurz is on twitter complaining about Goodrow lol

he still defends Deboer too I’m sure.

 

[Pavelski2112]

He said it's a good return, but that the Sharks have no forward depth next year and that Goodrow was a great PK'er.

The Sharks didn't have forward depth this year either.

He needs to stop thinking of this team as a good team. We're not anymore. Get used to it.

 

[Pinkfloyd]

His entire argument is that a contending team needs cheap depth.

And that isn't a poor argument to make but reality is that Goodrow is still pretty replaceable and getting a 1st for him is much more than he really should get in the trade market even with how cheap his contract is. Sometimes, selling high still makes the most sense.

 

[hohosaregood]

Or trade both the 2020 2nds to move the 2020 TB 1st from 26th to 23rd haha

I purposely blocked that possibilty from my mind because I didn't want to be sad

 

[Sysreq]

I mean we'll see what the 1st round pick turns into. Goodrow was a good soldier for the team. Played the right way, always gave 110% and was fantastic on PK as a result. I think it's going to be a lot harder to replace Goodie than a lot of people realize. Players like that don't just appear out of no where. We'll see if we can turn that 1st into something worth while, but honestly, it's probably gonna be like 27OA.

 

[Sharksrule04]

Kurz really thinks keeping Goodrow and Melker makes more sense than getting a top sixer and replacing the bottom six

I feel like he's purposely doing devils advocate. If a team offers you a first round pick for Goodrow, you take it. Plain and simple. You can probably trade that first rounder on draft day for a much better player than Goodrow.

 

[hockfan1991]

Or trade both the 2020 2nds to move the 2020 TB 1st from 26th to 23rd haha

You would get 3 spots with one of those picks

 

[Coily]

Odd that every "insider" has gone dark since the Cousins news...