The OP would need to stipulate that this isn't a debate for the status quo ante, given Karlsson's current contract status. His rental status makes this a non-starter. Period.
That would end a pretty interesting conversation, though. So let's have him sign a seven-year extension at $11M/yr, a front loaded, lockout protected, bonus laden deal like that which Tavares signed for the sake of simplicity.
If he were signed along these lines, or agreed to sign as part of the trade, it would be an interesting question, particularly since Toronto desperately needs defense and the front office doesn't agree with that premise. Or at least it says so; I'm not sure I believe this TML position is sincere.
As for the Sharks, signing Tavares appears to have been their first choice this summer, and trading for Karlsson their second choice.
Summary: Both teams ended up adding to a position of strength, and still have real weaknesses in the other area. Fascinating.
Personally, I would do it if I were either club. I think the Sharks would do it. The Leafs would wrestle with what their hearts and their heads are telling them. I think they'd pass.
That would end a pretty interesting conversation, though. So let's have him sign a seven-year extension at $11M/yr, a front loaded, lockout protected, bonus laden deal like that which Tavares signed for the sake of simplicity.
If he were signed along these lines, or agreed to sign as part of the trade, it would be an interesting question, particularly since Toronto desperately needs defense and the front office doesn't agree with that premise. Or at least it says so; I'm not sure I believe this TML position is sincere.
As for the Sharks, signing Tavares appears to have been their first choice this summer, and trading for Karlsson their second choice.
Summary: Both teams ended up adding to a position of strength, and still have real weaknesses in the other area. Fascinating.
Personally, I would do it if I were either club. I think the Sharks would do it. The Leafs would wrestle with what their hearts and their heads are telling them. I think they'd pass.
