canuckster19
Former CDC Mod
Problem is everyone will try and get away with holds then on a 4th and 10 situation, I understand the rationale behind automatic first downs and have no problem with it.
NFL GDT: Super Bowl LVII: (AFC) Kansas City Chiefs vs (NFC) Philadelphia Eagles
- Thread starter MMC
- Start date
Problem is everyone will try and get away with holds then on a 4th and 10 situation, I understand the rationale behind automatic first downs and have no problem with it.
I think the hold was either the only or the second subjective call all game.
OPI on Eagles Pascal on the second drive. He was clearly over a yard past he LOS when he engaged. So not sure how subjective you can argue that.
All others on Philly were illegal hands to face on Suh, offside unabated on Sweat, delay of game on Hurts. Pretty iron clad calls.
KC only had 3 pre snap calls. Lining up offside (not improved for the NE games that they could have won).
We’d have to get views of all 75 or whatever drop backs to see if there were any illegal contact which can be called even if the QB doesn’t look to that side of the field.
But it was a very clean player game. Was it just the 3 flags for OPI, hands to the face, and defensive holding that were during the play calls? I think everything else was pre snap. Refs didn’t call anything outside of the clear obvious ones. Let them go at it for the most part. Not a single holding call on the OL though FG these are 2 excellent lines so not unexpected.
Last edited:
Quid Pro Clowe
Registered User
Oh wow, expedited replay can ACTUALLY stop a Davonta Smith drop and get the call right?? 49ers and their fans didn’t know that….
After getting every single call and non call from last game into the 2nd half of this one, fans still complaining about a clear hold by Bradbury. L O L.
After getting every single call and non call from last game into the 2nd half of this one, fans still complaining about a clear hold by Bradbury. L O L.
It was under 2 minutes in the half. So, all reviews at that point in time are done by the officials. They can buzz down and take their time to review. Different than the SF game.
Last edited:
John Price
Bet
- Sep 19, 2008
- 374,446
- 25,121
Breakers
Make Mirrored Visors Legal Again
So the NFL paid $8 million for that field
And it took 2 years to grow
Fire or sue whoever grew that shyt.
My god
And it took 2 years to grow
Fire or sue whoever grew that shyt.
My god
NFL did something similar with the SF Levis' stadium field. Used some new turf. SB probably not the best time to experiment with something new. Use basic grass that has been used in other stadiums.
I mean, next year's SB is in LV, a very similar climate to Glendale. Figure it out so that we don't get this bad footing. Plus, maybe don't paint the field aside from the end zones and mid field. Didn't they used to just paint the midfield mark with the SB logo. This year it was the NFL logo in the middle and SB# at the 30.
AZ has had that stadium for over a decade now. Haven't they figured out what grass to use by now?
Just keep it simple.
BrindamoursNose
Registered User
- Oct 14, 2008
- 20,148
- 14,266
Spring in Fialta
A malign star kept him
Nothing against you dude but holy crap you're about to turn into a sentient salt shaker. The game was weeks ago (and the Niners didn't challenge and also lost by 24 points).
He is also forgetting that this SB Smith catch was inside 2 minutes so it’s a booth review more so than an expedited review. Anything that the booth isn’t sure on they buzz down and take a look. Vs having to find an angle before the next play is run.
Quid Pro Clowe
Registered User
Why even have booth review if it’s super selective then. I thought the point was getting all the calls right, or is it just getting the calls right in the last 2 minutes.
You guys just wanted to blame Shanahan and Shanahan alone while absolving the refs and booth at the same time. Now it’s be quiet because time has passed. Man, f*** that shit.
It’s funny how you guys pretend like game-changing calls aren’t a big deal unless they happen to your teams.
Spring in Fialta
A malign star kept him
As it was explained to you, the refs screwed up. And then the Niners compounded the refs mistake with one of their own. That's still on them.
It sucked then but the truth is that the Niners were completely f***ed no matter what the instant Purdy went down and that the Niners media tour whinefest just has them looking like complete babies. That call is so low on the list of reasons as to why SF lost the game.
It was still on SF. Eagles were rushing to the line to run a play. You can’t rely on the expedited review when the other team is rushing to the line and trying to quickly run the next play. If Philly was taking their time and using up the entire 40 second clock then the expedited review maybe picks it up but Philly was moving to get it snapped in around half that time.
SF S was pointing to HC to challenge. It’s a big play so worth the risk of one of your 2 challenges. TO in first half not an issue it’s more so the challenges. But a successful challenge would have taken that TD off the board and given SF the ball. You have the challenges available to you. Up to the team whether they opt to use them. When the result could be a turnover on downs best to challenge it if you are not convinced it was a catch.
Nfl doesn’t want to replay everything. Would slow the game down. The expedited review will basically give HC more challenges on essence. So with that in hand, no reason to save your challenges. Don’t need to go Mike Martz with them but if there is a big enough reward best to use them.
Between turnovers, scoring plays, final 2 minutes, expedited reviews and coaches challenges, nfl can review basically all the key plays. But when there is a time crunch with a team rushing to the line, onus will turn to the HC to challenge.
Last edited:
Gurn
Registered User
- Jan 23, 2023
- 399
- 489
DangleCity
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2016
- 7,184
- 3,380
If we are gunna play this game. I could say the same thing about Mahomes loldid Brady out play him, or just found a way to cheat, that no one caught onto?
Bias doesn't necessarily have anything to do with it. If they called a penalty that has been ignored on both sides all game that is unacceptable and the official should be blackballed.
Gurn
Registered User
- Jan 23, 2023
- 399
- 489
do you have any link/story that reports, or alludes to Mahomes being a cheater?
Voight
#winning
Seriously. All we heard all week is how they rivaled the 84/85 Bears defence. Granted they faced a weaker opponent but they did rip off 7 sacks.
BrindamoursNose
Registered User
- Oct 14, 2008
- 20,148
- 14,266
Seriously. All we heard all week is how they rivaled the 84/85 Bears defence. Granted they faced a weaker opponent but they did rip off 7 sacks.
That is not what we heard. Come on.
What you heard was the D-line rivaled the 85 Bears in the sacks department specifically because quite literally they did (statistically)
Philly fans, as a whole, don't truly blame the refs for the game. We know we didn't play as well as Kansas City. That last call on 3 & 8 is just a call that despite it being a hold by the rulebook, it is believed it shouldn't have been called purely because it was a little ticky-tack. That effectively ended the game on a ticky-tack call.
That's all.
Voight
#winning
MikeyMike01
U.S.S. Wang
Travis Kelce Achieved Peak Self-Delusion By Believing The World Gave The Chiefs No Chance To Win Super Bowl LVII
Travis Kelce, you absolute ledge, with all due respect: What the actual f*** are you even talking about?Below is the longer version of the clip where once again Kelce crashes Patrick Mahomes' postgame...www.barstoolsports.com
Kelce's nobody believed in us comment was hilarious. Bro thinks they're the 07 Giants
A real miracle run from the #1 seed in the AFC
Voight
#winning
Moose Head
Registered User
Really I had no pony in this race but Show me where it was ignored. Have yet to see it.
Anyone complaining that the refs screwed the Eagles is wrong. I dont like the fact that they didn't call any holding penalties all game but the Eagles had to make one stop in the 2nd half and couldn't. The end. The Eagles lose a bunch of defensive players and Ideally their coordinators but they have the best quarterback in the NFC and their offense will be dynamic. It's an offense league.
Ad
Upcoming events
-
-
-
Gold Medal 2024 IIHF WORLD CHAMPION - PICK ONLY ONE TEAMWagers: 7Staked: $36,600.00Event closes- Updated:
-
-