I think that's more a factor of how ready they assess Evans to be. He looks great in the AHL, but it's a big ask to step from AHL rookie to an everyday NHL player the following season. If they don't sign Dumoulin and Evans isn't ready, then Megna has to play every game. Also they were unusually healthy on defense last season I think, otherwise we probably would have seen his NHL debut already.
Look at Kartye. I saw him listed on a top 100 prospects list for the whole NHL. This time last year he was an undrafted nobody. I think that shows that if a kid is ready, he'll get the opportunity.
According to everyone who watched Evans play he looked really good especially during the pressure moments of the AHL playoff run and the calder cup final.
Still, I'm not sure you sign a guy for two years with Megna around as well.
Of course unless Francis watched Megna and doesn't rate him at all.
Comparing Kartye to Evans makes no sense.
Evans was an overager taking at 19 years old in round two of the draft and also has just as much AHL experience as Kartye.
Kartye is a great story and it's easier for forwards to make the jump but he doesn't have more experience at the pro level than Evans.
Though, I agree you don't rush prospects.
I disagree. A slower approach would mean giving the kids more of a chance to be ready than throwing them into the fire. Dumo is a stop-gap.
Personally, I enjoyed the run last season, but I am ok regressing this season. Be patient and wait to see if some subset of Wright, Winterton, Melanson, Evans, Nelson, Firkus, etc. are impact players in 2024-25.
I do agree with you that we are a middling team right now. This team could repeat and make the playoffs again but that is far from a guarantee.
It depends on the prospects.
Like I've said Evans was drafted as an overager potentially keeping in mind he might be faster to the NHL and help inject more youth in an expansion draft roster that was mostly betweend the ages of 28 - 32.
Overall I've got no problem with grooming those guys, even a little bit longer than most would, but I still don't really get that Doumoulin signing for two years.
I also don't have a problem with us maybe regressing a bit and drafting closer to the top ten, cause I think another higher end prospect would be good going forward to build around Beniers, Wright, Sale and those other guys.
Though, I'm not going to be mad if we have another year like last season but at that point you probably have to start looking into trading a first round pick in order to find that game changing player we're lacking.
So let's see what Francis does and how that Dunn contract will look like.