Speculation: Rumors/Speculation/Trade Talk - 2018-19

[Doshell Propivo]

I feel pretty bad about it tbh. Rather move Leddy their way, especially after Chiarelli'comments about how they don't have any good passing defenseman.

Neither do we.

 

[Le Grec]

I feel pretty bad about it tbh. Rather move Leddy their way, especially after Chiarelli'comments about how they don't have any good passing defenseman.

RNH is currently playing at a PPG pace and has 65 points in his last 79 games, so I doubt Edmonton would be interested in moving him without addressing their real needs.

Would you prefer including Toews instead of a pick, or doing Leddy for RNH straight up?

 

[scott99]

How do you all feel about this proposal...

To Edm:
Beau
JHS
2nd

To NYI:
RNH

RNH is really meshing well with McDavid, I don't think they would trade him.

 

[Glory Days]

I like that Lamoriello keeps things close to the vest, but I really hope he's making some offers for Nylander. He would be a perfect #2 center behind Barzal. I would offer Nelson & Beauvillier (Bellows takes his place). Do you guys an gals think that would be enough ?

I think Toronto would want D instead of 2 forwards.

 

[Glory Days]

Would you prefer including Toews instead of a pick, or doing Leddy for RNH straight up?

Leddy for Nurse would be my offer. Oilers get their puck moving D and Isles get a player who is better in the D zone.

 

[doublechili]

Leddy for Nurse would be my offer. Oilers get their puck moving D and Isles get a player who is better in the D zone.

If we traded Leddy for Nurse, EDM fans would then tell us that Leddy is better than Nurse. So we should make it Leddy for Nurse+.

 

[Kevin27NYI]

In a series of moves, trading Eberle for a 1st+ and trading Leddy for Nylander would help us in the coming years. If we could swing for the fences with Erik Karlsson in the offseason we're in prime real estate.

 

[Macch]

In a series of moves, trading Eberle for a 1st+ and trading Leddy for Nylander would help us in the coming years. If we could swing for the fences with Erik Karlsson in the offseason we're in prime real estate.

Let's check in and see how Karlsson is doing with the high-powered Sharks...

 

[Kevin27NYI]

Let's check in and see how Karlsson is doing with the high-powered Sharks...

I'm fine with that, I will buy low.

 

[Seph]

Would you prefer including Toews instead of a pick, or doing Leddy for RNH straight up?

I still don't see Edmonton taking either deal with how well RNH's been playing.

 

[Jack Johnson]

I Know About A Pair Of Trades That Lou Lamoriello Can Make,Righ Now,To Upgrade The Power Play.

The First Trade That He Would Make Is Anthony Beauvillier,Stephen Gionta,Kiefer Bellows & Michael Dal Colle To The Columbus Blue Jackets For Artemi Panarin.

The Other Trade That He Would Make Is David Quenneville,Devon Toews,Robin Salo & Sebastian Aho To The Minnesota Wild For Ryan Suter.

After He Make Those Trades,Barry Trotz Would Then Be Able To Set Up Their Lines Like This.:

Left Wing-Center-Right Wing

Artemi Panarin-Mathew Barzal-Jordan Eberle
Anders Lee-Brock Nelson-Josh Bailey
Andrew Ladd-Valtteri Filppula-Leo Komarov
Matt Martin-Casey Cizikas-Cal Clutterbuck

Left Defense-Right Defense

Nick Leddy-Johnny Boychuk
Ryan Suter-Ryan Pulock
Thomas Hickey-Luca Sbisa

Starting Goalie

Robin Lehner

Backup Goalie

Thomas Greiss

 

[Lame Lambert]

 

[Zeeker]

The legend himself is back boys! I’ve been waiting for this day...

As for the proposals themselves, interesting ideas Jack but the lack of a certain Kris Versteeg makes me hesitant to approve of them.

 

[beach]

I Know About A Pair Of Trades That Lou Lamoriello Can Make,Righ Now,To Upgrade The Power Play.

The First Trade That He Would Make Is Anthony Beauvillier,Stephen Gionta,Kiefer Bellows & Michael Dal Colle To The Columbus Blue Jackets For Artemi Panarin.

The Other Trade That He Would Make Is David Quenneville,Devon Toews,Robin Salo & Sebastian Aho To The Minnesota Wild For Ryan Suter.

After He Make Those Trades,Barry Trotz Would Then Be Able To Set Up Their Lines Like This.:

Left Wing-Center-Right Wing

Artemi Panarin-Mathew Barzal-Jordan Eberle
Anders Lee-Brock Nelson-Josh Bailey
Andrew Ladd-Valtteri Filppula-Leo Komarov
Matt Martin-Casey Cizikas-Cal Clutterbuck

Left Defense-Right Defense

Nick Leddy-Johnny Boychuk
Ryan Suter-Ryan Pulock
Thomas Hickey-Luca Sbisa

Starting Goalie

Robin Lehner

Backup Goalie

Thomas Greiss

421

 

[SI90]

Ryan Suter LmAo

Maybe if this was 2012

 

[BrockLobster]

I Know About A Pair Of Trades That Lou Lamoriello Can Make,Righ Now,To Upgrade The Power Play.

The First Trade That He Would Make Is Anthony Beauvillier,Stephen Gionta,Kiefer Bellows & Michael Dal Colle To The Columbus Blue Jackets For Artemi Panarin.

The Other Trade That He Would Make Is David Quenneville,Devon Toews,Robin Salo & Sebastian Aho To The Minnesota Wild For Ryan Suter.

After He Make Those Trades,Barry Trotz Would Then Be Able To Set Up Their Lines Like This.:

Left Wing-Center-Right Wing

Artemi Panarin-Mathew Barzal-Jordan Eberle
Anders Lee-Brock Nelson-Josh Bailey
Andrew Ladd-Valtteri Filppula-Leo Komarov
Matt Martin-Casey Cizikas-Cal Clutterbuck

Left Defense-Right Defense

Nick Leddy-Johnny Boychuk
Ryan Suter-Ryan Pulock
Thomas Hickey-Luca Sbisa

Starting Goalie

Robin Lehner

Backup Goalie

Thomas Greiss

I Forgot About This Guy. Welcome Back Jack

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

I Know About A Pair Of Trades That Lou Lamoriello Can Make,Righ Now,To Upgrade The Power Play.

The First Trade That He Would Make Is Anthony Beauvillier,Stephen Gionta,Kiefer Bellows & Michael Dal Colle To The Columbus Blue Jackets For Artemi Panarin.

The Other Trade That He Would Make Is David Quenneville,Devon Toews,Robin Salo & Sebastian Aho To The Minnesota Wild For Ryan Suter.

After He Make Those Trades,Barry Trotz Would Then Be Able To Set Up Their Lines Like This.:

Left Wing-Center-Right Wing

Artemi Panarin-Mathew Barzal-Jordan Eberle
Anders Lee-Brock Nelson-Josh Bailey
Andrew Ladd-Valtteri Filppula-Leo Komarov
Matt Martin-Casey Cizikas-Cal Clutterbuck

Left Defense-Right Defense

Nick Leddy-Johnny Boychuk
Ryan Suter-Ryan Pulock
Thomas Hickey-Luca Sbisa

Starting Goalie

Robin Lehner

Backup Goalie

Thomas Greiss

I Don't Post As Much As I Used To But I Need To Acknowledge How Great These Moves Are. Great Work, Jack.

 

[scott99]

In a series of moves, trading Eberle for a 1st+ and trading Leddy for Nylander would help us in the coming years. If we could swing for the fences with Erik Karlsson in the offseason we're in prime real estate.

Hate to tell you, NOBODY is giving us a 1st for Eberle, let alone a 1st+. And considering Leddy's last 2 years, it may take more than Leddy for Nylander.

 

[Kevin27NYI]

Hate to tell you, NOBODY is giving us a 1st for Eberle, let alone a 1st+. And considering Leddy's last 2 years, it may take more than Leddy for Nylander.

Lol why

 

[majormet]

I Know About A Pair Of Trades That Lou Lamoriello Can Make,Righ Now,To Upgrade The Power Play.

The First Trade That He Would Make Is Anthony Beauvillier,Stephen Gionta,Kiefer Bellows & Michael Dal Colle To The Columbus Blue Jackets For Artemi Panarin.

The Other Trade That He Would Make Is David Quenneville,Devon Toews,Robin Salo & Sebastian Aho To The Minnesota Wild For Ryan Suter.

After He Make Those Trades,Barry Trotz Would Then Be Able To Set Up Their Lines Like This.:

Left Wing-Center-Right Wing

Artemi Panarin-Mathew Barzal-Jordan Eberle
Anders Lee-Brock Nelson-Josh Bailey
Andrew Ladd-Valtteri Filppula-Leo Komarov
Matt Martin-Casey Cizikas-Cal Clutterbuck

Left Defense-Right Defense

Nick Leddy-Johnny Boychuk
Ryan Suter-Ryan Pulock
Thomas Hickey-Luca Sbisa

Starting Goalie

Robin Lehner

Backup Goalie

Thomas Greiss

this is one of us, just positing under another name for sh!ts and giggles right? , although if we were tracking this as criminal, it is missing the signature "My New York Islanders"

 

[duster19]

If we traded Leddy for Nurse, EDM fans would then tell us that Leddy is better than Nurse. So we should make it Leddy for Nurse+.

Puljujarvi.

 

[BrockLobster]

Hate to tell you, NOBODY is giving us a 1st for Eberle, let alone a 1st+. And considering Leddy's last 2 years, it may take more than Leddy for Nylander.

Alot less got 1sts last year

 

[SI]

Alot less got 1sts last year

In a stronger draft mind you

 

[SI]

Also RNH is playing With McDavid - because Draisaitl needs to be the 2C and they have no one who can play with McD. So, playing RNH at LW with McD solves two problems. Long term? Don't know if it is a solution

RNH at 6m looks like a piece they can move for the right pieces. They need help at D and top 6 F's

 

[SI90]

Hate to tell you, NOBODY is giving us a 1st for Eberle, let alone a 1st+. And considering Leddy's last 2 years, it may take more than Leddy for Nylander.

I have to disagree.

Eberle is a legit top6 winger. A playoff team looking for more skill and scoring in the top 6 would absolutely give a mate first for Eberle st the deadline.

He’s the exact type of player that you wouldn’t mind giving up a 1st for at the deadline if you think you have a chance to go deep into the playoffs.