I imagine those who take issue with this deal are the same who really generally dislike the Copp deal as well. Both of these guys are effective middle 6 C/Ws who play really solid all-around games, bring a great level of effort and are more than inline with their market value rates.
Compher, and Copp as well, have and will continue to draw the hardest assignments this next season and provide a huge amount of relief, support and protection to our young players And boost up their stats while the boards will continue to moan “ohhh - they are just half point production! How terrible”. Except Copp in avg TOI for shothanded was seconded only to Seider at 2:27, higher than all of our other defenseman, and the next forward is Larkin at 1:47. Copp took the hardest assignments for the season and still ended +2 despite being 2nd in TOI for PK and 14th! In ATOI per game being even behind Sunny after he joined. Compher was 3rd behind Toews and Makar in PK ATOI at 2:08. We complain about their poor production except the roles they are asked to play are all about playing hard, energy sapping minutes in tough situations and they do a great job with it and despite not getting plum minutes in the PP, still produce above a PPG level. If you used them with more favorable starts, PP time and less defensively responsibilities, these guys are putting up much stronger numbers.
This is about adding more guys in the Jordan Staal, Ryan Kessler, JG Pageau, mold of players who can play middle six minutes, stabilize a line (ie have a revolving door of line mates and still keep it together or even make them better - a la Ras on Copps wing), be a damn fine PKer, still find a way to get us 40-50 pts, all for doing for the % of the total cap around Helm( 2016 @5% of cap vs JT at 6%).
We are so much better off with these guys holding down the fort for the next four years while we get to situationally shelter our prospects.