We almost won the presidents trophy in 2012 and that team was relatively dog **** in the playoffs.
Not the same thing. That team was lacking depth and then got hit by injuries. On defense, our third pair was a disaster made up of Dizzy and John Moore. Then Staal got injured in the first playoff game and so for 11 out of 12 playoff games, we played with half of our defense being MDZ, Moore and Eminger. Our worst defenseman on his worst day is better than all 3 of them combined on their best day.
Clowe got injured too and was replaced by Kreider who downright sucked that year. He had size and speed, but his brain at the time was inferior to that of the average AHLer (though the average AHLer doesn't have Kreider's tools). He stunk up the joint in the playoffs for the same reason he stunk in the regular season that year, and was very up and down even in the AHL in 2012-13. Pyatt played every game that season, playoffs and regular season. Asham was a regular along with Dorsett on the 4th line. To have a rookie Kreider, Pyatt, Asham and Dorsett all play at the same time is not exactly a sign of depth, particularly since Pyatt was a top-9 player. Hell Newbury managed to play in 3 playoff games, Haley and Hamrlik in two.
Hagelin is presently on our third line, and the lowest scoring player on our third line. At the time, he was our top-6 player. Brad Richards got all of 1 point in the playoffs. Totally useless. This board was exploding with Brad Hate.
So yeah, on a team where half the defense are #6/7 defensemen, and 4-5 forwards should be in the AHL, yeah, that team won't do much in the playoffs. But hey, even that team made the second round.
Overall, the two teams are incomparable. The Rangers were just hot in the shortened regular season because a few players like Stepan were hot for 40 games. If that were a full 82 game season, the hot streak would've ended and we'd have been exposed. At no point that year did I have any hope of winning the Cup.
This year we added Hayes, Miller, Fast, Dominic to replace Pyatt, Asham, Dorsett and Boyle among the depth players, which is a massive improvement. Yandle and Klein on defense to replace Moore and Dizzy is an even bigger upgrade. MSL's experience and skill will be more important than Cally's intangibles. Guys like Stepan, Zuccarello, Kreider are incomparably better players today.
This year's team would've swept the one two years ago if they could've played against each other.