Danault’s offensive instincts are very limited. That’s why you don’t put him on your top 2 lines. You could never win a cup with Danault on the 1st or 2nd C.
Depends on the rest of your lineup. Your idea of a lineup is very limited. If Tatar - Danault - Gallagher was your third offensive line in terms of production, but first in terms of TOI, because it went against and held opponents' top lines to less points than they garnered, you could have a winning team.
That would just mean that your other 6 players in the top-9 (TOI wise) benefitted from facing less opposition and being able to let there offensive instincts take over more, even if they had a few minutes less of ice time than Tatar - Danault - Gallagher did.
Danault having very limited offensive instincts, as you put it (even if you're exaggerating), doesn't prevent you from icing two other Cs and lines with superior offensive instincts, even of they don't face opponents' best lines (hence the lesser TOI). Lesser TOI can be used to exploit good players' energy level coming off shorter shifts where they were able to go balls to the wall during the entire shift.
Besides, the proper line mates for Danault, as we see with Tatar and Gallagher, can exploit Danault,s skill set and still lead to overall productive shifts, given the shutdown nature of the line, to begin with.
Your unwillingness to look at anything different than the model you have come up with for a line-up is what makes you unable to see any other possibilities.
Unfortunate as it fails to lead to any real conversation, IMO.
Many roads lead to Rome, even if All Roads Lead To Rome is a gross exaggeration.
That is so wrong. I have never seen a whole 3rd line each put up 50+ points in a season. That’s just insane and impossible for a team to get to because of the salary cap.
FYI, after Bergeron, Pastrnak, Marchand and Kreijci, the forward with most points in Boston had 42. Yet they were and still are regarded as a favorite to win the cup.
The 5th highest scorer of the Islander this year was Eberle at 37 points.
The 5th best F of the so-called powerhouse now that is the Blue Jackets is Boone Jenner at 38 points, and that’s including Duchene.
The so-called 2nd line in Vegas (technically your 4th, 5th and 6th best F, which is supposed to be in your top 6) was Tuch, Statsny and Eakin at 52, 42 and 41 points.
The 6th best F scorer of the Avalanche this year, Colin Wilson, finished with 27 points.
The 6th best scoring F for St-Louis, Schwartz, finished the year with 36 points.
The so called Toronto offensive powerhouse had Johnsson finishing 6th in scoring for forwards with 43 points.
Nashville’s 4th best forward, Craig Smith, finished the year with 36 points.
Dallas’s 4th, 5th and 6th best scoring forward respectively finished the year with 30, 27, and 26 points, yet they are 1 game away from eliminating Nashville.
I only went with the teams that are still alive in the playoff. Anyway, keep telling yourself Danault isn’t worthy of 2nd line role if it makes you feel better. He’d have 2nd line production on ALL the remaining playoff teams are still fighting for the cup