I think this is completely fair and a great mindset to have, but I don't think this justifies a lot of the complaints I've seen on here. Complaining about guys like ZAR, Sheahan and Grant as they're producing, just because they're vanilla and not skilled enough for you, is bogus. Complaining about Murray giving up a bad goal in a game where he's stopping 38 of 41 shots is bogus. Complaining about Oleksiak and Johnson being in the lineup, as they're not playing that poorly, is bogus. It's just people making stuff up to complain about.
I agree with some of that stuff for sure, I don't want any more than 1 of Oleksiak, Johnson or Maatta on the team for example. I just think some people just complain about players regardless of how they're actually playing, just because they want to complain.