Well the AAF looks to be dead already. The product on the field was pretty boring. They were also trying to market themselves as a minor league to the NFL and failed terribly. The no kickoffs pretty much killed it for me right off the bat. Most of these guys would be fringe/special teams players and they couldn't even showcase for that aspect of the big league. I feel like people that love the kickoff (Like me) are a dying breed.
.
.
.
Maybe the XFL will get it right this time. Almost assuredly not, but one can dream.
I for one do NOT need more f***ing football. The incessant overanalysis and blather over the NFL that stretches well over the season is enough for me. That's why I think the time has passed for football in America to really have a viable "spring league." The USFL was reasonably successful before Donald Trump singlehandedly ruined it, but that was 30 years ago. The NFL is too big, bloated, and omnipresent for there to be any sort of additional league.
The XFL will fail as badly last time as they did the first time. Somehow they managed to infuse football with WWE-style theatrics and stripper cheerleaders and it was still one of the most boring things I've ever seen on television. Their lasting legacy is Rod "He Hate Me" Smart and some of the camerawork they pioneered made its way into NFL broadcasts.
The AAF was a fool's errand. To try and convince the NFL that it could use a "feeder" league by trying to run an independent league of castoffs for (they estimated) three years even though the NFLPA didn't appear to be on-board at all and the CBA having no provisions to allow it just seems ridiculous. And then they grossly miscalculated the costs to boot.
I would've been completely for the AAF if it had set itself up as a viable alternative to player development to the NCAA. Man, that would've freaked out some really old, really rich, really fat white guys though.
The average length of a football player's career just doesn't warrant the idea of creation of some kind of "tweener" league between college and the pros.
Isn't there yet another off-season league being cooked up? I just wish these would go away entirely. Even arena football appears to be on life support.