b1e9a8r5s
Registered User
You're not. This was a good post.
Thanks, while I have you hear, since you seem to be the go to MLB guy around these parts, maybe you can answer this.
I asked this question earlier in the year, but I don't think anyone responded.
At what point is it beneficial for a player to give up switch hitting if one side is so much worse than the other? Moncada is crazy young, so I'm in no way arguing for it, but how many ABs, or what is the discrepancy that you would need to see to say it's not worth it?
Using Moncada as the example (again, he's super young, small sample size, etc)....
As a lefty 454 AB .226/.326/.451
As a righty 173 AB .170/.226/.229
Say that 3 years from now, those splits were a similar gap between batting right and batting left, would you scrap hitting righty all together? Is there any expectation of what he would hit as a lefty vs lefty pitching or is there no reasonable way to tell until he started doing it?
Again, this is more just a hypothetical question about switch hitting than Moncada himself (so calm down BWC).