Last year he had 57 points in 68 games, with 27 of those coming at even strength which is still great production (0.397 5v5 points per game is elite production), downplaying Barrie by using a year where he was better offensively than every other dman not named Karlsson is not smart on your end. Regardless, I think the last 5 years and over 300 games are a better indication of Barrie’s ability at 5V5, which is top 10 in the league any way you look at it. Somebody saying Barrie is a pp specialist is the easiest way to determine they don’t know the player and are using stereotypes to form an opinion, Barrie is elite 5V5 and has been for years.
No I’m not asking for the 10th or RNH, because I’ve repeatedly showed you why those pieces don’t get Barrie. I’ve used numbers, player comparables, and actual trade comparables all showing why RNH doesn’t get Barrie, but you still don’t acknowledge you’re prior ignorance on his value, instead you’re doubling down every chance you get. A decent addition like the 10th plus the 2019 1st or RNH + 10th for Barrie + 16th is what I’ve asked for, which is fair value.
Of course all those dmen are better than Barrie defensively, that’s the point I’m trying to make, if you want a dman that’s as good as Barrie offensively, and also good defensively, you’re asking for a Subban. If you want a Subban, Draisaitl is the piece that’s moving.