Confirmed with Link: Nylander Re-signs: 6 Year x $6.9 AAV Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.

thewave

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
40,545
10,489
One of the consequences of employing the holdout strategy to squeeze out more money is that Nylander has really put pressure on himself to perform in particular in the playoffs .

Rightly ,or wrongly a lot of fans did not like the fact that Nylander held out and didn’t play the first 20 games .

I’ve got to imagine that these fans will be particularly unforgiving if Willy pulls a disappearing act in the playoffs again . He will be roasted by fans and media alike if this happens .
A much higher salary brings with it much higher performance expectations .

It was a complete crapshow and it should have been ironed out in the summer. Dubas simply should have said 6.5 x 6, the Ehlers amount adjusted and it won't change a penny if you hold out or not even if you sit. That's what should have happened.

#sellyourNylanderMerch
 

ULF_55

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
84,214
16,288
Mountain Standard Ti
Visit site
That is a great contract they came up with.

Nylander's deal is so team friendly starting July 2nd. 2019.

Nylander got an extra $300k, and that bodes well for the next round. Marner and Matthews can get an extra $300k, and all the Leafs need do if find $1 million from amongst the other 20 players they put in the line-up.
 

Mess

Global Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
87,008
12,076
Leafs Home Board
Yeah Dubas said Nylander camp waited until the very last hour. they probably got desperate and called lol

2 Weeks ago on HNIC the panel said Nylander's camp was believed to be a shade under $7 mil in the 6.9ish range while the Leafs were about $500k apart at present putting them at $6.5 mil tops, and not yet willing to go to the Pastrnak deal as an official offer.

Pierre Lebrun tweeted last night Leafs managements position heading towards the dealine hour.


It looks like Gross and Nylander dug their heels in and Leafs had their FINAL and best offer weeks earlier, and Dubas/Shanny caved to their demands as the clock ticked down based on the final number of $6.96 mil being the same as the one reported earlier.

Nylander's side called the Leafs bluff and won.. They were holding all the cards so it wasn't unexpected that Leafs management eventually would accept that offer or close to it.
 
Last edited:

Pookie

Wear a mask
Oct 23, 2013
16,172
6,684
Dubas had only to do one thing... Tell Nylander he was worth Ehlers money on a comparable team and let the 6.5m x 6y offer sit there from the start with no movement even if it means him sitting. That's all he had to do and he buckled, he caved. He overpaid, thankfully in a way that a team like Carolina will see EXTREME EXTRA VALUE in.

Dubas signed a high end deal within the range for players of this type.

Shanahan made everyone think that they needed a less than elsewhere type deal. I’m not sure why he felt this was a good thing to say publicly.

The Lamoplan didn’t have free reign with Marleau. And the Dubaplan didn’t make it up on the fly with Nylander. There’s either a Shanaplan or there isn’t.

If there is an extreme overpay that will hurt this team next year it’s Marleau. A short sighted deal that Shanahan absolutely approved of.

He tried to fix his mistake on the back of a Rookie. Didn’t work.

Hopefully he shuts up when it comes to Marner, Matthews and Rielly.
 

TML Dynasty

Registered User
May 2, 2016
1,547
898
Gotta assume he's lost endorsement opportunities over this too? I mean if youre a major company looking for a member of the Leafs you have quite a few options.....why risk taking on a guy that a portion of the fan base may be not the happiest with. Wonder if he stays long term with reebok.
 

NiL8r87

Registered User
Jun 30, 2009
3,142
764
2 Weeks ago on HNIC they panel said Nylander's camp was believed to be a shade under $7 mil in the 6.9ish range while the Leafs were about $500k apart at present putting them at $6.5 mil tops, and not yet willing to go to the Pastrnak deal as an official offer.

It looks like Gross and Nylander dug their heels in and Leafs had their FINAL and best offer weeks earlier, and Dubas/Shanny caved to their demands as the clock ticked down based on the final number of $6.96 mil being the same as the one reported earlier.

Nylander's side called the Leafs bluff and won.. They were holding all the cards so it wasn't unexpected that Leafs management eventually would accept that offer or close to it.

Dubas got a big win by getting no NTC until the last year I think. That definitely couldve been a sticking point if Nylander was concerned about being traded as was rumored.
 

ToneDog

56 years and counting. #FireTheShanaClan!
Jun 11, 2017
24,073
22,422
Richmond Hill, ON
Dubas had only to do one thing... Tell Nylander he was worth Ehlers money on a comparable team and let the 6.5m x 6y offer sit there from the start with no movement even if it means him sitting. That's all he had to do and he buckled, he caved. He overpaid, thankfully in a way that a team like Carolina will see EXTREME EXTRA VALUE in.

You don't know who decided to cave. It could have been the board decided that they were better off overpaying rather than having him sit. The pressure of going all in this year probably had something to do with it. We got Willie for at least this year's run. Think of it as a Christmas gift from MLSE to all Leaf fans. We are in for some real exciting hockey.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blanche Blanche

Jackson14

Registered User
Feb 23, 2013
727
396
It was a complete crapshow and it should have been ironed out in the summer. Dubas simply should have said 6.5 x 6, the Ehlers amount adjusted and it won't change a penny if you hold out or not even if you sit. That's what should have happened.

#sellyourNylanderMerch

If only it was as easy as writing a post on a forum...
 

thewave

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
40,545
10,489
Dubas signed a high end deal within the range for players of this type.

Shanahan made everyone think that they needed a less than elsewhere type deal. I’m not sure why he felt this was a good thing to say publicly.

The Lamoplan didn’t have free reign with Marleau. And the Dubaplan didn’t make it up on the fly with Nylander. There’s either a Shanaplan or there isn’t.

If there is an extreme overpay that will hurt this team next year it’s Marleau. A short sighted deal that Shanahan absolutely approved of.

He tried to fix his mistake on the back of a Rookie. Didn’t work.

Hopefully he shuts up when it comes to Marner, Matthews and Rielly.

I see your take (spin) and I think it's pretty close to reality here.

Dubas should never have said Long term deals for all. STUPID NEGOTIATION TACTIC. High order dumb right there, like his exaggerated smile suggests. I think Shanahan should have kept his mouth shut as well, completely out of line saying that. Lou would never say these things because he is a smart enough negotiator to understand ANYTHING YOU SAY CAN AND WILL BE USED AGAINST YOU IN NEGOTIATIONS. The Marleau deal made sense to them at the time, trying to develop Matthews, not sure it actually did much of anything but enter a good father figure into the room. Yes they tried to correct mistakes but not really, the 6.5m on the table was actually fair, the 7m is overpay. We'll see how this pans out for the others.
 

Pookie

Wear a mask
Oct 23, 2013
16,172
6,684
Dubas got a big win by getting no NTC until the last year I think. That definitely couldve been a sticking point if Nylander was concerned about being traded as was rumored.

You can’t give a NTC until a player hits the age minimum.
 

thewave

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
40,545
10,489
You don't know who decided to cave. It could have been the board decided that they were better off overpaying rather than having him sit. The pressure of going all in this year probably had something to do with it. We got Willie for at least this year's run. Think of it as a Christmas gift from MLSE to all Leaf fans. We are in for some real exciting hockey.

That's true, it could be the board. Larry T has made all kinds of these exec decisions for the Leafs reportedly in the past. I am sure some of Burkes mistakes are on that very active owner/board member. Yes we have him for this year and he had better be brilliant and I mean that. He had better be the best version of himself we have ever seen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ToneDog

ToneDog

56 years and counting. #FireTheShanaClan!
Jun 11, 2017
24,073
22,422
Richmond Hill, ON
Gotta assume he's lost endorsement opportunities over this too? I mean if youre a major company looking for a member of the Leafs you have quite a few options.....why risk taking on a guy that a portion of the fan base may be not the happiest with. Wonder if he stays long term with reebok.

It was nice growing up as a Leaf fan when there was no talk of salaries (it was all game and not business) and fans simply judged players by their play on the ice. Now we have a great young player in Nylander and fans will judge him by his salary and this negotiation as well as his play. Let's hope he can get off to a quick start and win all his fans back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TML Dynasty

TheTotalPackage

Registered User
Sep 14, 2006
7,415
5,610
Whether or not Dubas caved (I think in the end he moved up to Nylander's number as opposed to Nylander moving down to the Leafs), he had to do it. There's absolutely no way he should have let such a small amount mean the difference between Nylander signing and him sitting out the entire season.

A lot of people suggested Dubas let him just sit the year. Prove a point. Show who's the boss. Don't get pushed around. Be the big winner by not letting a "punk" dictate things. I'm sorry, if he did that, Dubas would have been by far the biggest loser of it all and it'd have left a huge black mark on his resume early in his career. It would have meant he was unable to sign one of his best players, meaning he wouldn't play single game for an entire season for his team when the team is primed for a Cup run, and he didn't even get anything for him in a trade if the relationship was not going to be mended. Just let Nylander sit at home in Sweden or see him play elsewhere besides the Maple Leaf blue and white. Ridiculous.

Glad both sides came to their senses and got this done. All will be forgotten once he scores his first point off a beautiful play. And he'll once again prove why he is an absolute stud of a talent and not some guy that a player like Kapanen can replace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blanche Blanche

Buds17

Registered User
Nov 29, 2015
8,311
3,419
This whole “player holding out” issue can be resolved by lowering RFA compensation. It might be a little too many future assets for a cap league.

Lower RFA compensation just makes it more likely that a team will match IMO. The onus then moves to the offering team to structure the contract in such a way that the recipient team essentially can't match. Think it solves the player holding out issue, but it might lead to RFA contracts increasing that much more. That could pose a bigger problem.
 

SprDaVE

Moderator
Sep 20, 2008
52,618
34,516
2 Weeks ago on HNIC they panel said Nylander's camp was believed to be a shade under $7 mil in the 6.9ish range while the Leafs were about $500k apart at present putting them at $6.5 mil tops, and not yet willing to go to the Pastrnak deal as an official offer.

Pierre Lebrun tweeted last night Leafs managements position heading towards the dealine hour.


It looks like Gross and Nylander dug their heels in and Leafs had their FINAL and best offer weeks earlier, and Dubas/Shanny caved to their demands as the clock ticked down based on the final number of $6.96 mil being the same as the one reported earlier.

Nylander's side called the Leafs bluff and won.. They were holding all the cards so it wasn't unexpected that Leafs management eventually would accept that offer or close to it.

They split the middle basically. Nylander camp were at 8m plus.

So if you want to know who won, everybody did in a way. They split the difference.

If Nylander would have started at 7m, this deal doesn't take 2 months.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menzinger

BoredBrandonPridham

Registered User
Aug 9, 2011
7,573
4,061
Lower RFA compensation just makes it more likely that a team will match IMO. The onus then moves to the offering team to structure the contract in such a way that the recipient team essentially can't match. Think it solves the player holding out issue, but it might lead to RFA contracts increasing that much more. That could pose a bigger problem.

Absolutely, RFA contracts will increase proportionately, which means they are probably increasing to a more fair market value to their worth without holding out until Dec 1 to get it.
 

ToneDog

56 years and counting. #FireTheShanaClan!
Jun 11, 2017
24,073
22,422
Richmond Hill, ON
They split the middle basically. Nylander camp were at 8m plus.

So if you want to know who won, everybody did in a way. They split the difference.

If Nylander would have started at 7m, this deal doesn't take 2 months.

Would be interesting to know if Nylander accepts 6x$7M in the summer. If he would have he basically got paid for sitting out three months.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheTotalPackage
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad