Marshall
A ribbon reflector
I don't think the contract is particularly detrimental to the Islanders organization as a whole, but taken on its own it does seem a bit odd.
Lou just watched his high flying Leafs team get their asses handed to them in the playoffs because they had diddly squat for toughness. Guess he's not planning to make that mistake again.
1-way/2-way absolutely does matter, and it matters a ton. With 2-way, you're talking about a ~5x pay increase when he's in the NHL compared to AHL. 1-way and he's guaranteed to get the money no matter what.Can be buried at next to no cap hit.
1 way/2way shouldn’t matter to fans, unless your team is the Sens, pinching every penny
Like I said above, in addition to just wasting money for no reason, you are also risking losing a fan favorite type of player. For no reason. It's just dumb. He could've never asked for 4 years himself. He could've never asked for more than 1M/yr at any point in the future in his career. There was literally no reason to hand this guy this much financial security, and as a result possibly lose a popular 4th line hungry clown because of it. It's just fundamentally stupid to initiate that sort of thing on this type of player.I said it on the Islanders board, i’ll Say it here.
This is literally a no risk move for anyone associated with the Islanders except for the owners. He works out? Great! Cheap, young, serviceable 4th liner with a bit of upside. He doesn’t? Oh well, send him back to BPT and he either gets claimed or he goes to the minors and it doesn’t impact the Islanders cap at all.
The only people who should hate this deal is the Islanders owners since they have to pay him a million bucks even if he gets sent down to the minors
1. It’s not my money, the owners can spend it however they choose.Like I said above, in addition to just wasting money for no reason, you are also risking losing a fan favorite type of player. For no reason. It's just dumb. He could've never asked for 4 years himself. He could've never asked for more than 1M/yr at any point in the future in his career. There was literally no reason to hand this guy this much financial security, and as a result possibly lose a popular 4th line hungry clown because of it. It's just fundamentally stupid to initiate that sort of thing on this type of player.
Not a bad point. 12 depth forwards were dealt for either a pick or prospect at the deadline this year.1. Sign all the bottom 6 guys you can afford
2. Keep them until trade deadline when contenders come in and might be willing to overpay to get depth or upgrades for picks and/or prospects
3. ????
4. Profit
I wouldn't mind that, but I'd prefer they don't tank it too hard in the upcoming years. The pieces of a playoff team are their, they just need to add one or two guys.Not sure why people aren't acknowledging the obvious tank set-up Lou is putting together here?
He's probably overpaying fourth liners so they can hit the cap floor over the next few years based on whatever they're projecting.
Given the term on these guys, seems like they're gonna go for a three year tank job, just enough time to go into their new arena with elite prospects.
I'd be happy if I was an isles fan.
It's weird but there's no downside. What is the risk here?It's a buryable so it's not like it will hurt them cap wise if it doesn't work, but it's just weird giving a player like him 4 years of term. Seems unnecessary. Most guys like him go year to year at those cap hits. Is he really going to get so much better than you'll be happy you don't have to pay him 1.5 million in 2 years time instead?
And I have heard of him before. He was the guy that meant the Isles wouldn't want Martin back again. Good times!
This is absolutely ridiculous.1-way/2-way absolutely does matter, and it matters a ton. With 2-way, you're talking about a ~5x pay increase when he's in the NHL compared to AHL. 1-way and he's guaranteed to get the money no matter what.
Imagine the difference in your mentality and in your work rate at your job if you were working for a possible 5x pay increase, vs making that money on default and having no possibility to get a raise. What a ridiculous suggestion that that sort of incentive doesn't matter. These kind of fringe players are pure effort and hustle who are really just trying to make a living their whole career with mostly minor league salaries, they are much closer to the average person than your average NHLers' millions, so this financial incentive is an extremely relevant thing regarding these types of players' effectiveness on the ice.
“Never heard of this guy”Never even heard of this guy. What a bad and odd signing
I wouldn't mind that, but I'd prefer they don't tank it too hard in the upcoming years. The pieces of a playoff team are their, they just need to add one or two guys.