Diamond Joe Quimby
A$AP Joffrey
So what's the value of the future return you stated compared to signing him for 5x125-150m.
Based on projections / opinion etc.
Well, I'm a proponent of the old man Donaldson + da kids (i.e. Turner + Seager\Bellinger) going forward, so I would resign him.
The prospects are hard to quantify. Reyes has ace level stuff (similar to Carlos Martinez), but could never get healthy, and turn into a reliever or nothing. O'Neill might be nothing (or could be Jason Bay reincarnated), and Perez might be nothing (or could be a starting shortstop). Its a roll of the dice.