If you are allowing some players to shirk their defensive responsibilities, then yes, I think that makes someone a bad coach.
The original point still stands -
The team was coached to include more of a D game in the prior year - why did it not happen last season?
I heard the same message over and over again from this coach - you need to work, move your feet, get on pucks, etc.
They didn't execute on the coaches message and part of that is on the coach for not getting the team to execute -
But, how much of that falls on the players, especially the leaders, who thought better and did it their way - cheating on O and playing outside the game the coach preached.
It's easy to blame it on the coach - you see enough of that on here to get that message loud and clear.
Did the players learn anything based on the results? Is our team leadership now realizing that the winning formula was the one from the prior year and the losing only took place after moving away from what worked? Do you really think the coach preached a more O game and less D to this group?
Or could it be that the players now get it - and know what they need to do to be successful. Hopefully they used the summer to reflect on this past season.
IMO, you take a young team (out side of Wheels) that is still learning what it takes - and they learn the hard way. They see the results and the methods over the last two years and begin to understand the difference - primarily, which was more successful. So you take what you learned and apply it - meaning you buy into what the coach has always preached and move on. Is it a stretch to believe this scenario?
I'm not trying to absolve this coach from all responsibility and if they come out of the gate (again) with a total disregard for the coach and his game, then you need to make changes and that likely means the coach is gone - and that may happen. But I also know that this org is going to continue to push their agenda with an acceptance and understanding that young teams learn and they that sometimes means they learn from their mistakes.