Lol more to winning than just scoring goals,You do have to win the puck,win battles along the boards,and play physical in front of your net.....Skill is just one of the ingredients
Exactly, this board just gets caughts in these binary arguments of skill vs grit or size vs skill. The size vs skill binary was one of the leading factors that prevented a large contingent of posters from seeing the value in Tkachuk. They had a hard time wrapping their heads around it and still do.
Some skill players, no matter the size, will use their flash and dash to to get in the dirty areas to make nice pass or close in snipe. However, a lot of skill players vanish in the playoffs once the physical play and tight checking ramp up. They can't effectively deal with time and space taken away. I am sure we can think of plenty of examples.
Then you have these guys like Devante Smith-Pelly scoring big goals in last year's playoff run. The lumbering guy had like 7 goals. I believe he had 3 in the SCF.
Or Collin Wilson having an impact thus far in these playoffs.
A lot of these nice playoff passing plays are the result of relentless work, and physicality and pressure.
The playoffs are often a war of attrition. Can you make plays under a lot of duress? This becomes more true as the playoffs move on
Datsyuk, one of my favourite players, constantly made skill plays while being tightly checked. It was his skill, compete and relentless that made him so special.
Just watching the U18s, I don't care if Cozens has a better skill set. I would take Krebs over him everyday, even though he is smaller and less perhaps less skilled in the abstract.