NHL and NHLPA Prefer to play some regular season games if they are able to resume playing

ryerockarola

Registered User
Nov 20, 2011
6,000
7,586
In the end, if the players and the league collectively agree to this format, then we as fans should just take it and run. The parties involved set the parameters
Yeah basically. It just seems a bit weird that if the top 4 teams' seeding doesn't change and there's upsets in the first round that the No.1 team wouldn't play the lowest-seeded team left after the play-in rounds. Under this format if Chicago (12) beat Edmonton they'd play Dallas (4) next not St. Louis (1). It would make sense to re-seed the teams but like you say just take it and run.
 

ps241

The Ballad of Ville Bobby
Sponsor
Mar 10, 2010
34,904
31,384
Yeah basically. It just seems a bit weird that if the top 4 teams' seeding doesn't change and there's upsets in the first round that the No.1 team wouldn't play the lowest-seeded team left after the play-in rounds. Under this format if Chicago (12) beat Edmonton they'd play Dallas (4) next not St. Louis (1). It would make sense to re-seed the teams but like you say just take it and run.

thing is though that “bracketing” element Is consistent with how the NHL have rolled for a long time. Not saying they couldn’t have taken this opportunity to re-seed to actually set the formal playoffs but they seem hooked on the bracketing idea :huh:. I agree I think I might have had the play in then re-seeded but whatever there is so much dam parity that who knows what works best?
 

ps241

The Ballad of Ville Bobby
Sponsor
Mar 10, 2010
34,904
31,384
I honestly don't really care what the format is. It isn't a typical year so we aren't going to get a typical format. All the complaining about what if Montreal or Chicago win a round is getting a bit silly. You need to beat whoever your opponents are to win a cup.
I honestly don't really care what the format is. It isn't a typical year so we aren't going to get a typical format. All the complaining about what if Montreal or Chicago win a round is getting a bit silly. You need to beat whoever your opponents are to win a cup.

100% agree

The playoffs are so long and it’s such a grind that the winner always earns it. Last season all the first seeds got knocked out so it’s not like it isn’t unpredictable anyways.
 
Last edited:

ryerockarola

Registered User
Nov 20, 2011
6,000
7,586
thing is though that “bracketing” element Is consistent with how the NHL have rolled for a long time. Not saying they couldn’t have taken this opportunity to re-seed to actually set the formal playoffs but they seem hooked on the bracketing idea :huh:. I agree I think I might have had the play in then re-seeded but whatever there is so much dam parity that who knows what works best?
Bracketing is consistent with how the NHL has rolled for awhile but the pandemic's thrown a curveball to everyone so all things should be considered. But I think that's just early-morning mild complaining on my part after having nothing even solid to consider for awhile regarding what might happen. Basically I'm ok with anything, if anything's ever decided. :) edit: as long as Detroit's not allowed in the playoffs, I wouldn't be ok with the only team mathematically eliminated from the postseason making it into the playoffs. But since this 24-team format guarantees Detroit's not in, whatever else they decide is ok
 
  • Like
Reactions: ps241

nobody imp0rtant

Registered pessimist
May 23, 2018
10,812
17,977
Some interesting reading about the Bundesliga return to play.
https://www.si.com/soccer/2020/05/22/bundesliga-behind-scenes-closed-doors-schalke-dortmund-germany

When you think about all the rules and restrictions, how many people would have to follow them to the letter, for a much longer period than what it will take for this soccer league to wrap up its play, given the overall more... hmm, what's a good word for it... undisciplined culture that we have in Canada and the US...

Do people really see this working out to the point of having the Cup being awarded? God, this guy couldn't even make it to the restart. :laugh:
Bundesliga: Augsburg boss Heiko Herrlich breaks quarantine rules and will miss restart
 

TS Quint

GET THESE ADS OUT OF MY WAY!
Sep 8, 2012
7,906
5,245
Some interesting reading about the Bundesliga return to play.
https://www.si.com/soccer/2020/05/22/bundesliga-behind-scenes-closed-doors-schalke-dortmund-germany

When you think about all the rules and restrictions, how many people would have to follow them to the letter, for a much longer period than what it will take for this soccer league to wrap up its play, given the overall more... hmm, what's a good word for it... undisciplined culture that we have in Canada and the US...

Do people really see this working out to the point of having the Cup being awarded? God, this guy couldn't even make it to the restart. :laugh:
Bundesliga: Augsburg boss Heiko Herrlich breaks quarantine rules and will miss restart
He left the hotel to buy toothpaste....... yeah, sure he did. There was no toothpaste he could buy in the hotel? The team doesn't have helper monkeys to go get toothpaste for him if they don't have any in the hotel?

This sounds like the classic Simpson's line "Quick! Think of a lie. I was at a pornography store. I was buying pornography".
 

cbcwpg

Registered User
May 18, 2010
20,246
20,862
Between the Pipes
Some interesting reading about the Bundesliga return to play.
https://www.si.com/soccer/2020/05/22/bundesliga-behind-scenes-closed-doors-schalke-dortmund-germany

When you think about all the rules and restrictions, how many people would have to follow them to the letter, for a much longer period than what it will take for this soccer league to wrap up its play, given the overall more... hmm, what's a good word for it... undisciplined culture that we have in Canada and the US...

Do people really see this working out to the point of having the Cup being awarded? God, this guy couldn't even make it to the restart. :laugh:
Bundesliga: Augsburg boss Heiko Herrlich breaks quarantine rules and will miss restart

The NHL wants to isolate and quarantine all it's players so they can finish the season / playoffs ... which means quarantining mostly a bunch of 20 year olds who don't want to be. Las Vegas should have a pool to bet on what players get caught breaking out of quarantine first.
 

KingBogo

Admitted Homer
Nov 29, 2011
31,715
39,936
Winnipeg
I honestly don't really care what the format is. It isn't a typical year so we aren't going to get a typical format. All the complaining about what if Montreal or Chicago win a round is getting a bit silly. You need to beat whoever your opponents are to win a cup.
I for one like that there will be a playoffs no matter what form it takes. The Jets are in so we have a punches chance with Helly.
 

Eyeseeing

Fagheddaboudit
Sponsor
Feb 24, 2015
22,196
36,845
I for one like that there will be a playoffs no matter what form it takes. The Jets are in so we have a punches chance with Helly.
Hey I thought the idea was daft but it it changed the tone around here
I’m all in for others to totally enjoy
 

Mortimer Snerd

You kids get off my lawn!
Sponsor
Jun 10, 2014
57,451
29,295
So you prefer the Jets not be in it? I'm not thrilled by the format but it will do for this 1 season . The analogy I would use is would you rather lose in a fair game or win ugly? I would take winning ugly any day of the week.

No, it isn't that I prefer the Jets not in. If they played up to a 74 game total and Jets made it, I would be happy with that. If they expand to 24 teams and just make up a 24 team PO, I would be happy with that.

This play in round with 1/3 of the teams having a bye is the kludge. Those 8 teams are playing for seeding. It is just to get them playing the rust off.

This way, 8 teams that earned PO spots are forced to play against 8 teams that did not in order to keep their PO spot. But the other 8 teams are not.
 

wpgfishfan

Registered User
Apr 1, 2014
605
341
Only reason this is not getting killed here is Jets at 20th would have been knocked out. Montreal being 9 games under .500 are in the playoffs is silly. They should have gone to 16 for 2 reasons.

1. We played over 80% of the season which is more than enough.
2. Easier to protect 16 teams from Covid than 24
 

KingBogo

Admitted Homer
Nov 29, 2011
31,715
39,936
Winnipeg
Only reason this is not getting killed here is Jets at 20th would have been knocked out. Montreal being 9 games under .500 are in the playoffs is silly. They should have gone to 16 for 2 reasons.

1. We played over 80% of the season which is more than enough.
2. Easier to protect 16 teams from Covid than 24
They went with 24 for the main reason they are even doing this in the first place, so they can recapture as much of the lost revenue as possible. Going with 24 teams instead of 16 brings in the following markets and fan bases of the NYR, Chicago BlackHawks and Montreal Canadiens: Seems a bit silly to put on a TV event, which this basically is and then not include 3 of the top the top 5 markets of the viewing public.
 

surixon

Registered User
Jul 12, 2003
49,183
70,546
Winnipeg
They went with 24 for the main reason they are even doing this in the first place, so they can recapture as much of the lost revenue as possible. Going with 24 teams instead of 16 brings in the following markets and fan bases of the NYR, Chicago BlackHawks and Montreal Canadiens: Seems a bit silly to put on a TV event, which this basically is and then not include 3 of the top the top 5 markets of the viewing public.

Bingo!
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Agar

raideralex99

Whiteout Is Coming.
Dec 18, 2015
4,915
9,704
West Coast
Only reason this is not getting killed here is Jets at 20th would have been knocked out. Montreal being 9 games under .500 are in the playoffs is silly. They should have gone to 16 for 2 reasons.

1. We played over 80% of the season which is more than enough.
2. Easier to protect 16 teams from Covid than 24
Actually the Jets had the first WC spot and were only 2 points behind Dallas with the same amount of wins when the season stopped. In fact only 10 of the 23 playoff teams have more wins than the Jets so to say they are 20th and don't deserve to be in the playoff is stupid. Also no team under .500 is making the playoffs. The 24 team playoff format is the right thing to do plus it makes the most sense.
 

cbcwpg

Registered User
May 18, 2010
20,246
20,862
Between the Pipes
The Tampa Bay Lightning was one of two teams to vote no on the NHL’s proposed 24-team return-to-play plan for the Stanley Cup playoffs.

Tampa isn’t fond that its first-round opponent will get a best-of-five play-in series before it plays the Lightning.

Carolina was the other team to vote no.
 
Last edited:

nobody imp0rtant

Registered pessimist
May 23, 2018
10,812
17,977
Getting the teams to sign off on the format of the "playoffs" is one thing and the easy part. Getting 600 players etc. to quarantine to play those playoffs, another thing all together...

https://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/nh...ily-a-hot-topic-as-nhl-plots-return-1.5583108

I'm counting on Laine to get our boys back to their families as soon as possible. :laugh:

CrazyHelpfulAustrianpinscher-size_restricted.gif
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad