Value of: Make Your Proposal for Sean Monahan

[*OvechKiN*]

Too many untouchables for a 1B / 2A Center entering his prime and on a good contract for 3 more years.

Flames don’t want crap overpaid players or 2B/3A players and magical 3rd round picks.

 

[CraigsList]

Jost for Monahan

Bennett for Landeskog

 

[CraigsList]

Has Monahan's value declined a lot? Some of these offers are horrendous.

No, it's just posters who don't have a clue on a player who is playing just fine as a 1C. Is he a top 15C in the NHL? No, but he gets the job done while the Flames don't have a 1C replacement.

 

[the_fan]

Bennett for Landeskog

If this two trades happened, gotta give the W to Sakic.

Jost for Monahan=massive win for Avs
Bennett for Landeskog=big win for Flames

 

[Johnny Hoxville]

If this two trades happened, gotta give the W to Sakic.

Jost for Monahan=massive win for Avs
Bennett for Landeskog=big win for Flames

Bennett and Monahan for Landeskog and Jost?

 

[the_fan]

Bennett and Monahan for Landeskog and Jost?

Yes

 

[Holystik]

You're such a fan boy that you'd probably say you wouldn't trade Suzuki straight up for Monahan.

I would not.
Rather take the gamble of a controlled AAV younger player during the cap crunch. Also I am pretty confident Suzuki can be a 60 point centre and if lucky better.
So...
Nope.

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Flames don't really need Landeskog. They already have a much better version in Chuckie.

I would trade Moahanan straight up for Kadri though. Kadri is a gamer. Imagine Kadri and Chuckie on the same line.

 

[Volica]

I think Calgary would be open to moving Sean for a high end RW as well. With Treliving’s comments about Lindy as centre; have to think there may be something in the cooker to give the core a shakeup.

There just isn’t enough ice time to go around down the middle for Calgary if they are dedicated to moving Lindholm to centre full time, not when Backlund is elite at what he does; and Bennett showed to have another gear centring his own line.

I said this on the Flames board, there’s something we don’t see happening here; because the moves they’ve been making the past couple weeks are great but also the forward group is busting at the seams when it comes to legitimate NHLers.

 

[zizbuka]

Krejci + Debrusk for Monahan + Bennett

JVR and Ghost for Monahan and Bennett.

 

[Volica]

JVR and Ghost for Monahan and Bennett.

Ryan + Lucic for Giroux and Frost.

 

[CraigsList]

JVR and Ghost for Monahan and Bennett.

give your head a shake.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Flames don't really need Landeskog. They already have a much better version in Chuckie.

I would trade Moahanan straight up for Kadri though. Kadri is a gamer. Imagine Kadri and Chuckie on the same line.

LMAO what? Kadri is a time bomb. Monahan is a much better player and isn't going to throw an entire game (hell even series) for you just because he can't control his mental. He's like Zach Kassian but actually decent at hockey. I would have happily taken him as a 2C last year in the nixed Brodie trade but no way in hell would I ever consider moving Monahan for him.

 

[McJedi]

No, it's just posters who don't have a clue on a player who is playing just fine as a 1C. Is he a top 15C in the NHL? No, but he gets the job done while the Flames don't have a 1C replacement.

Which screams out. Don’t trade him.

Or do trade him and expect about 70 cents on the dollar. Hence probably not a good idea to explore trades for this player and have hissy fits when you find out he’s not particularly valued by other teams at the moment.

if he’s valuable to the Flames. Keep him.

 

[McJedi]

LMAO what? Kadri is a time bomb. Monahan is a much better player and isn't going to throw an entire game (hell even series) for you just because he can't control his mental. He's like Zach Kassian but actually decent at hockey. I would have happily taken him as a 2C last year in the nixed Brodie trade but no way in hell would I ever consider moving Monahan for him.

For a much better player, Monahan sure has an odd tendency to disappear in playoff games. Those games and moments matter to some fans and GMs.

 

[Nanuuk]

Monahan has been in 4 play-off series. In two of them he played injured and required off season surgery/rehab.

In 2014-15, he played in 11 games and had 6 points.
In 2016-17, he played in 4 games and had 5 points.
In 2018-19, he played in 5 games and had 2 points.
In 2019-20, he played in 10 games and had 8 points.

I wouldn't say he disappears in the play-offs. It is a team game.

 

[HyPnOtiK]

That’s not a bad offer. I’m probably in the minority but I’d do that in a heartbeat. Danault is about equal to Monahan at this point, Byron would be amazing in our bottom 6 and flip Tatar to the highest bidder. I’m all for it.

I think Danault is a very underrated player but this is going too far. Monahan is one season removed from PPG and is a steady 70 point C imo.

 

[HyPnOtiK]

Montreal gets fleeced in a deal like that. Danault on his own is better than Monahan.

Wow, i hope this is general consensus and Philly makes a move to steal him.

 

[HyPnOtiK]

I would not.
Rather take the gamble of a controlled AAV younger player during the cap crunch. Also I am pretty confident Suzuki can be a 60 point centre and if lucky better.
So...
Nope.

Well.... You're doing it based off cap so I can respect that. My gripe would be with claiming Suzuki is a better player. Monahan is becoming one of the most underrated players in the league.

 

[CraigsList]

Your offers barely get Sam Bennett people lmao.

 

[heilongjetsfan]

Last time this happened was in 2005(?) when the Sharks got Joe Thornton for Brad Stuart, Wayne Primeau and Marco Strum. Before that, was it the Gretzky to L.A. trade? Trading for a 1c is incredibly rare.

Vegas traded theirs last month for a 3rd and a guy Winnipeg got off the waiver wire.

You don't need to be a HOF nominee to be considered a 1C, just one of the top 31 players at that position.

Domi, and Kadri come to mind. RyJo, O'Reilly -twice, Stastny has been with 5 teams now if you count Winnipeg twice. People trade centers. Even legit ones.

 

[Sensfourlife]

Ottawa:

Monahan

Calgary:

L.Brown
Lassi
2nd RP 2021

 

[Mrfenn92]

Easy no for the flames

 

[Karl Eriksson]

Yes. This might be the Sens version of Ryder, Halak and a 3rd

 

[OvermanKingGainer]

Flames Sharks Blockbuster

This benefits both teams in my opinion.