- Feb 5, 2010
- 47,807
- 18,621
Basically if he tells you I'm not resigning here, you try to get something for him. Something is better than nothing.
Alternatively you do the player a solid by giving him a chance to win a Cup.
Confirmed with Link: Kulikov to EDM (Conditional 2022 4th round pick)
- Thread starter Zajacs Bowl Cut
- Start date
Basically if he tells you I'm not resigning here, you try to get something for him. Something is better than nothing.
Alternatively you do the player a solid by giving him a chance to win a Cup.
Saw that Larson was a UFA after this seasons, Do you think Edmonton is going to resign? I wouldn't mind him coming back to NJ.
hidek91
Registered User
Well, Jets are the most likely opponent of Oilers but my point was that no matter which opponent Oilers face in the playoffs, their chances aren't (in my opinion) higher than 60% so it's actually closer to the coin flip than some people want to admit. There's a good chance that they win the first round but they may very well get bounced so the return should be treated as somewhere between 3rd and 4th, which IMO is too low for Kulikov.
The list of d-men that returned more than Kulikov has been almost completed by you, the only two missing are Siegenthaler (not a rental though) and Savard. There were not many d-men traded in general but Kulikov, while limited offensively, has been one of those who could be put in the top 4 situation on the contending team and still look like he belongs, I don't think that could be said about many defensemen traded in recent days.
tr83
Nope, still embarassed
Devil made me do it
Registered User
Fitzgerald needs to learn how to play hardball and be stubborn at times. A 4th is useless in this weak draft. Better off keeping the guy.
SteveCangialosi123
Registered User
Devils731
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2008
- 12,336
- 16,448
That would have biting off your nose to spite your face.
A 4th or 3rd isn’t much but it’s more helpful than a few more games of Kulikov.
MachoDiablo
Registered User
Yeah, this is what it is: Devils aren't making the playoffs, so get something for Kulikov now, see if he'd like to come back in the offseason, and if he doesn't then at least you got some kind of asset for him. Meanwhile, you allow some of the younger guys to assume a bigger role over the final 15 games or so and see if that tells you anything heading into next year.
As for the return, yeah, it's pretty weak, but that's mostly indicative of the market this year. Fitz likely didn't have much leverage in a deal like this; Devils gain nothing by holding onto a guy who's overplaying his typical stat line this season and thus a likely regression candidate, and the market was flooded with decent third pairing defensemen to begin with. Again, best to get at least something for the guy, hope Edmonton wins a round, and then either use that pick next year or see if it can work as part of a future trade package.
As for the return, yeah, it's pretty weak, but that's mostly indicative of the market this year. Fitz likely didn't have much leverage in a deal like this; Devils gain nothing by holding onto a guy who's overplaying his typical stat line this season and thus a likely regression candidate, and the market was flooded with decent third pairing defensemen to begin with. Again, best to get at least something for the guy, hope Edmonton wins a round, and then either use that pick next year or see if it can work as part of a future trade package.
HugeInTheShire
You may not like me but, I'm Huge in the Shire
I would have liked to see the return be better for sure, but this is most certainly the best return that was offered, it's not like Fitz was going to take less to send him to Edmonton.. all the nonsense about it being a poor return and we should have just kept him, maybe he wanted out and lets not forget draft picks can be used for more than just selecting players
Ripshot 43
Registered User
- Jul 21, 2010
- 13,778
- 10,545
There is no "weak draft" or "strong draft" in the 3rd or 4th round. People define weak and strong drafts based on the expected upside of the top 5 to top 10, but beyond that statistics and probabilities tell us it should be about the same every year.
Billdo
Registered User
Almost every year is a year they say it's a weak draft until it's not. Are there any generational players in this one? Probably not but this draft will produce some All Stars, maybe a HOFer or two, but they've got to be found. Just like every other year.
Zajacs Bowl Cut
Lets Go Baby
so a conditional 4th is the same as nothing? If no one is offering anything more, what is the dude supposed to do....?
what a weird post.
Bratt, Wood, Maltsev and Sharongovich are all guys drafted after the 4th round that are currently playing right now. Three of them are in pretty big roles for us currently. I would take a chance at drafting another guy who has potential to become another player like any of them over keeping Kulikov for another 15games in a season were we miss the playoffs.
He’s been superb - our most reliable defenseman, you are getting a first or second pairing guy with a depth of experience. He’s heavy, mobile and can clear the crease. Makes a great first exit pass and can also skate it out. Great judgment and steadiness under pressure, rarely makes a mistake. He will help you on your playoff run for sure. He’s in fact just what you need. Should be a great playoff guy because he will stay at home and hit and has seen it all. Good luck to him and to your club.
Did I want more? Yes. Would I rather re-sign him as opposed to that price? Yes
I’m sure there just wasn’t a demand for him or Fitz would’ve got a better return.
That being said. That fourth night seem like nothing but people forget that quite often a fourth is used in order to move up 3-5 spots in earlier rounds and it is always good to have an extra one of those to ensure to get the guy you want.
This draft is going to have more steals than any draft in history due to the lack of scouting due to covid. You are going to see more late first round guys and second round guys having better careers than normal. It isn’t a deep draft like last year but the lack of knowledge on players can be beneficial to other GMs outside of the top 15
I’m sure there just wasn’t a demand for him or Fitz would’ve got a better return.
That being said. That fourth night seem like nothing but people forget that quite often a fourth is used in order to move up 3-5 spots in earlier rounds and it is always good to have an extra one of those to ensure to get the guy you want.
This draft is going to have more steals than any draft in history due to the lack of scouting due to covid. You are going to see more late first round guys and second round guys having better careers than normal. It isn’t a deep draft like last year but the lack of knowledge on players can be beneficial to other GMs outside of the top 15
I am thinking Kulikov is happy with the move. That we would not have otherwise done it. We owe him really because we have gotten such value out of his money. He has not been well paid here by his historic standards (two 4 times 4.5 contracts before he landed here supposedly washed up) but we permitted him to resurrect his career. Now a playoff run with a gifted team would put a nice accent on his year.
While just speculation, and idealistic at that, I would like to think we were doing something positive for the guy.
glenwo2
LINDY RUFF NEEDS VIAGRA!!
Oilers in NS
Registered User
- Oct 11, 2017
- 12,011
- 11,469
Thank u very much
I remember him from Junior actually. He was a good dman
Maybe we can resign in offseason. Who knows. We are off for this week till Saturday so he will only miss 2 games after isolating for a week
With NJ he was an excellent 2nd pair Dman that could fill on the first pair in a supportive role but but may not provide as much offense as you'd like.
The downside is he was significantly better in NJ than he was in Winnipeg. Is it a systems thing or was it because he got his skating back?
He also hasn't had a fully healthy season in 6+ years. He's been fine so far this year but it doesn't mean he isn't still injury prone.
The downside is he was significantly better in NJ than he was in Winnipeg. Is it a systems thing or was it because he got his skating back?
He also hasn't had a fully healthy season in 6+ years. He's been fine so far this year but it doesn't mean he isn't still injury prone.
Devil made me do it
Registered User
Stay put and have Holland make his move and offer more?
That's what Shero was a genius at. Trades. Fitzgerald is doing a good job but needs better bargaining skills when it comes to trades. Can't let an old geezer like Holland get the better of you.
Dialamo
Fire Rogalski Hire Pepe
Mgd31
Registered User
Shero also made bad trades, that's while saying this isn't a bad trade.
Zajacs Bowl Cut
Lets Go Baby
You mean like when he wouldn't trade Coleman until the price was met?
Oh wait.
