Value of: Islander Trades

[Paladin2799]

If Nylander already is reluctant to sign in Toronto why on earth would he want to sign for NYI?

Nylander isn't reluctant to sign in Toronto because of the location. He is reluctant to sign at a discount in Toronto because he worries that he would immediately get delt for a defenceman and he can't sign a NTC.

If he gets traded then all those worries go away because hes obviously been traded. You'd just pay him the 8m or whatever he wants, and he would sign.

 

[SI90]

Just read about how Chiarelli wants a puck moving defenseman. Isles need a 2c. Would a base around Leddy for Nugent Hopkins be something that can work for both teams. If the answer to that question from an Edmonton perspective is no, then what in your opinion would have to be added to make the deal feasible?

Leddy + Nelson + for RNH + Nurse

 

[Beautvillier]

Not interested in moving a main piece, was looking more for a rental type deal. If NYI doesn't plan to resign Ebs, I'd be interested in a rental deal.

rental type deal for a guy locked in until 2022?

 

[CREW99AW]

Leddy + Nelson + for RNH + Nurse

Were is Garth when we need him?

 

[Critical13]

rental type deal for a guy locked in until 2022?

Eberle? His deal ends this year

New York Islanders - CapFriendly - NHL Salary Caps

 

[Sparksrus3]

is there any purpose to this thread ? Islander fan here but this is just random wet paper towels tossed at the blackboard while the teacher has her back turned.

 

[CREW99AW]

is there any purpose to this thread ? Islander fan here but this is just random wet paper towels tossed at the blackboard while the teacher has her back turned.

I think the thread starter hopes to see Lou stock up on high draft picks + good prospects.
Not a bad idea if Lou is not interested in bringing back Nelson and Eberle, but makes no sense in Bailey's case or even Lee ( unless he cannot be signed).

 

[Kevin27NYI]

I’d move Eberle and Leddy.

Keeping Nelson, Lee and Bails.

 

[yianik]

Not an Isles fan, but I just dont see why the Isles would have a fire sale. They have some good young players and more in the system. I can see a move or two, but a full tear down seems unnecessary at this point.

 

[member 147413]

I'd be interested in a leddy+eberle for Nylander+ deal if there is interest on both sides.

Nylander would give the islanders plenty of talent.

Maybe they see eberle playing the same sort of role as nylander at a more reasonable caphit.

That’s crap for Toronto

 

[Beautvillier]

Eberle? His deal ends this year

New York Islanders - CapFriendly - NHL Salary Caps

you mentioned leddy, but for eberle a first + a b prospect i think i’d be ok with

 

[CREW99AW]

Not an Isles fan, but I just dont see why the Isles would have a fire sale. They have some good young players and more in the system. I can see a move or two, but a full tear down seems unnecessary at this point.

Lou said in one of his first interviews , that this is a retool and not a rebuild, that he has more pieces in place on LI then he had when taking over in Toronto.

So, you are right.Lou does not see the isles needing a full tear down.

 

[CREW99AW]

I’d move Eberle and Leddy.

Keeping Nelson, Lee and Bails.

What kind of contract would you want Nelson to receive?

 

[HoweHullOrr]

I am curious.
Did you expect nyi fans to want your late first?
Maybe your 3rd liners?

How about our classic 3rd liner (#6 defender) + 2nd round pick + B prospect? Its a tradition for us.

 

[Critical13]

you mentioned leddy, but for eberle a first + a b prospect i think i’d be ok with

I mentioned Leddy?

 

[Stuzchuk]

Ouch.

I as well think that Nylander is excessive

idk... Tim Liljegren + 1st (or 2nd+3rd) something in that line (cap dump if needed)

 

[Liferleafer]

Lou said in one of his first interviews , that this is a retool and not a rebuild, that he has more pieces in place on LI then he had when taking over in Toronto.

So, you are right.Lou does not see the isles needing a full tear down.

Well he's not wrong....Barzal, Lee, Bailey and a defense that can actually defend is far ahead of what he had here in 2015.

 

[CREW99AW]

How about our classic 3rd liner (#6 defender) + 2nd round pick + B prospect? Its a tradition for us.

I have seen several Leaf fans offering up Gardiner as a key trade piece. The fact he is a ufa in 8 months should evidently not concern the other team.
The Leddy for Gardiner proposal was worth a chuckle

 

[HoweHullOrr]

I have seen several Leaf fans offering up Gardiner as a key trade piece. The fact he is a ufa in 8 months should evidently not concern the other team.
The Leddy for Gardiner proposal was worth a chuckle

We do what we do. We make a lot of posts like this, and then claim to others when this is pointed out that we don't. Of course, we have a huge fanbase, so they run the gamut. There is that, which is valid of course, but I think lots of ppl hide behind that. That's when we like to play the persecution card.

 

[CREW99AW]

I as well think that Nylander is excessive

idk... Tim Liljegren + 1st (or 2nd+3rd) something in that line (cap dump if needed)

Isles are stacked with quality ,blueline prospects: Pulock,Dobson, Toews, MVS, Wortherspoon, Wilde.
No interest in Liljegren . I would much rather see the nyi develop their own promising blueline prospects.


Also, isles have no cap issues.

Would like to see Lou land a quality young center like RNH for the 2nd line or even a high end center prospect.

 

[Sparksrus3]

How about our classic 3rd liner (#6 defender) + 2nd round pick + B prospect? Its a tradition for us.

Ah yes, the years of the Leafs offer being Kulemin and a 3rd for all the best players . Let us not forget the Cody Franson add as a sweetener if needed. The good ole days here in HF were only a few years ago.

 

[bernmeister]

Rangers pass on OP players offered.
Only interest is in Dobson, and I doubt we could get on the same page as to value, but feel free to prove me wrong.

 

[IODCPiper]

Ouch.

Leafs are scoring a ton without him. Think if you added leddy to that back end. fair trade imo

 

[Kevin27NYI]

What kind of contract would you want Nelson to receive?

5x5 I think

 

[CREW99AW]

Rangers pass on OP players offered.
Only interest is in Dobson, and I doubt we could get on the same page as to value, but feel free to prove me wrong.

I did not see Dobson listed.

Is he upcoming ELC going to be too much for Malkin & Ledecky?