transclo
Registered User
- Oct 8, 2004
- 7
- 0
transclo said:Who will be the best player in few years?
borro said:Semin. He has already shown he can produce at the NHl level. Horton has not. He has seemed to be a disappointment. Now, it could be they are intentionally bringing him along slow. Semin is tearing up the RSL at a point a game clip, rare in that league. His game and his confidence have skyrocketed. He is very shifty and creative and COULD wind up playing with Ovechkin. Semin played first line on a bad team and produced. He is getting better and better.
Like shoyen said, I do believe Horton scored 14 goals last season. Poor research hurts your credibility a bit, borro.borro said:Semin. He has already shown he can produce at the NHl level. Horton has not. He has seemed to be a disappointment.
Mr.Hunter74 said:I would take Horton wihtout a doubt. Not that Semin isn't a good player which he is gonna be. I just like Hortons total package compared to the partial package in Semin. People should take into consideration that "Power Forwards" take the longest to develope out of all the forward types. Look how long it took for Iginla, Bertuzzi, Tkazchuk and even Neely to complete there developement and be the players they are now/where. So considering that Horton at 18 was already playing at such a high level just before he got injured just shows the elite potential this guy has. I thnk Semin gonna have alot of success in Washington but in the end its woudl you rather have a Power Forward or Skill Forward. I love Power Forwards so I would have to pass on Semin.
Horton Rocks, Cant waite to see Horton and Stewart on the same line..ouch hate to be the opposition defenseman. :lol
So the Panthers future top line will be either Wiese or Olesz/Horton/Stewart.. Washington has a awsome future top line as well but they desperatly need a center for Ovechkin and Semin. Maybe Aulin and Klepis will turn out or will be adequate enough to play the position until the team fins an elite type center to play with Ovechkin. It woudl be awsome for the Caps if they could turn Fehr into a center.
Garfield said:Horton.
Semin may still turn out to be a very good player but he hasn't impressed me all that much. Horton on the other hand was playing great before he got injured last year. Horton will also have more leadership skills IMO, he's better defensively, obviously tougher, so Horton for me with ease.
I can't wait to see Horton play in the WJC, Canada is going to be some hard to beat this year, fluky goals or not.
EroCaps said:Hasn't impressed you? Wow, you act like he's a bust- he was a rookie last year, played 50 games w/ 12 min average of ice time. I'm willing to bet you saw very little if any of him.
Semin was outstanding last year for the Caps...he's the most dynamic offensive player the Caps have had since Bondra, (outside of Ovechkin). I watched this kid play all last year and he has some of the best puckhandling skills I've ever seen. He's tearing up the RSL, also.
I'd take Horton by a whisker, bc he'll be a total two way force, but to say it isn't close is off, w/Semin's potential.
borro said:Semin. He has already shown he can produce at the NHl level. Horton has not. He has seemed to be a disappointment.
transclo said:Who will be the best player in few years?
wilka91 said:Semin is better ... if he stays in Russia.
Russian show no leadership in North America at all, period.
Legionnaire said:IMO Horton will be the best player from his draft class. Better than Zherdev, better than Staal, and better than Fleury
wilka91 said:Semin is better ... if he stays in Russia.
Russian show no leadership in North America at all, period.
By the way you write it, I'm not sure if you're talking about Semin or all Russians in North America.wilka91 said:Semin is better ... if he stays in Russia.
Russian show no leadership in North America at all, period.
Those are just stereotypes that will die. In a few years, comments like yours will disappear, just like when a few years ago on this board a horde of simpletons were clamoring that Euro goalies couldn't lead a team to the cup. Now they've disappeared and gone back to whatever stinkhole of ignorance they came from, thankfully.
Til the End of Time said:Horton, by a considerable margin.
Give me a break. They have exactly the same amount of points in the NHL, with Horton playing a total of three more games than Semin. But somehow Horton is a disappointment?
It is totally obviously that you haven't the slightest idea of what you are talking about. Do you even know anything about Horton, or did you just automatically pick the player on the team you support, as I suspect?
Frolov 6'3 said:Like shoyen said, I do believe Horton scored 14 goals last season. Poor research hurts your credibility a bit, borro.
This "insight" from the guy who called Horton a "disappointment"borro said:Horton is a top5 pick and Semin was not even picked top 10 and they have almost equal production. Advantage Semin
Semin plays on a first line against first line competition. Horton does not: Advantage Semin.
Horton plays more games-doesn't get more points. Advantage Semin.
The teammates Semin plays with are a stripped down version and he has little talent with him. Advantage Semin.
So where does this considerable margin come from? I personally expect a Top5 pick to play the year he is drafted with the possible exception of a goaltender and maybe dman. I consider it a disappointment if they dont. Getting back to your point, here are several reasons. Where is your CONSIDERABLE margin, or are YOU just picking the team you support? Try basing it on some NHL performance.