I know we talked about it last season, but we need to rejigger the goalies some how. Varlamov took a loss and got torched tonight and was still worth 4.85 points. I got some (deserved) crap a page or two ago about the goalies I'm carrying, but if they do anything they are worth more than pretty much any skater I can grab out of the free agency pool outside of riding some guy on a hot streak. Howard's been a tire fire but still averages 7.27 per start.
7.27 per start is strong, but consider you can only start 2 goalies any given evening and he's not playing every game. Even with that average, he's sitting at rank 390. There's about 60 players on waivers who have scored more points. And that assumes you used one of your goalie slots on Howard for every single start he's had - if you have 3-4 goalies, you're almost never going to get all your goalie starts played for a week. Not true if you're carrying 3 great forward or defenders. I never have to bench Burns. I do have to bench Binnington sometimes.
So goalies do get more built-in points than skaters, that's true, but if they didn't they'll never match skater totals. There's less than 30 routine starting NHL goalies. So while their overall value is skewed higher, there's far few of them in our pool.
So even with our totals a shade inflated, zero goalies are in the top 10 in scoring. And only 6 are in the top 30.
If you have the #10 goalie in the league, he's overall #46.
If you have the #10 skater in the league, well... he's #10.
Only 19 goalies make our top 100. And again to get every single earned point, that would assume you played them every single start, which is probably impossible.
I kind of like the way those numbers look at raw value, but I do understand what you're talking about. And it's why I wanted to look at the numbers again this year. After digging a little deeper, if we scale back goalies more, I'm not sure they become valuable at all unless they are a surefire top 10 starter.
Even the elite ones like Binnington (rank 34) can be a bit feast or famine. While Elvis has been the #1 players in the league over the last 2 weeks with 110.65 points (6 wins, 3 shutouts, .959 sv% - insane numbers), Binnington was the #183 player over the last 2 weeks with 33.90 points (still won 3/5 games there). Aside from lofty, unsustainable numbers, the secret to Elvis' big totals were playing over 400 minutes - also very unusual. He's started 10 straight games including back-to-backs, which is never going to happen routinely.
I just see those numbers and think for a goalie to be #1 he has to basically start every single game, win 80% of his games, and get shutouts in half his games. Good luck, eh?
The last two weeks the #10 goalie nets you 49 points if you start him every game (Jarry). The #10 skater gets you 63 points, who you are guaranteed to be starting every game (Auston Matthews).