Team Leo Komarov, because for some reason the OP forgot to include NONE as an option so I went with the next best Blue and White Disease overrated player on that roster.
There is no leader / captain on that team. Hasn't been one since Sundin left. They have good role models, like Lupul and Polak, but they aren't captain material. Not in this market.
So don't name a captain until one appears ready to be named. First and foremost, make it a guy who can both: a) talk smartly to the media, and b) has respect around the league.
It gets really tiring hearing Phaneuf's generic cliché answers as a fan who wants answers. It also gets frustrating seeing Dion get pushed and punked by opposition players, and not be stuck up for by his own players.