I actually think the offer is fair.
Those are going to be late 1st round picks, you’re pretty going to the conference finals each year. Especially if you can keep everyone together.
You don’t need any other additions on defence when Karlsson can eat all of those minutes.
Breaking down the value
1-top prospect (expected)
2- 3 1st round picks, probably late and also staggered. One of them being FIVE years from now.
3-Kapanen looks promising but he isn’t some top line elite winger.
4-Gardiner is alright, I like him.
Leafs are also in our division, so we want to be compensated for facing our former captain the next 7 years.