Unless a player dominates they aren’t considered a “lock”? What nonsense. Q.Hughes is a point per game defence and drop him in our line up today we would be vastly better. His defensive game will come around, EK65 took several years at the NHL level for that to happen.
Dahlen is doing fine and adjusting to N.A. ice.
Demko is just back from a concussion.
OJ (not mentioned) is running the pp1 in Utica right now and has 12a in 18 games.
Our prospect pool is good.
As I said, all the Dmen that were 1st round picks on our team were picked early because they put up a lot of points, not because of their D. I'm sure all the teams and fans that drafted them were convinced that they would be top players on their team too.
Look, I am pro tank...but this doesn't mean I want our prospects to tank too. I would love nothing more than a new GM to be that much closer to having a good pool of prospects to start with. After years of disappointment, I am not so easily convinced all our prospects will make it...even the 1st round picks. Dmen with questionable abilities to defend are not an automatic lock for me unless we only want them on the PP...
PPG for Hughes is good, but weren't we all expecting more since he went back? Drop him in our lineup today and our PP looks good, but 5 on 5? Is his defensive game NHL ready or even AHL ready? Yes, there's time and I hope he can. He has a good IQ and he can skate...no argument, but will his size hinder him down low along the boards or in front of the net? There's are as many questions as there promises, and from seeing the "surefire" 1st round Dmen on our team...to just assume that he is an NHLer is a little premature for me.
Dahlen, last few comments on his game, it sounds like he's not progressing well and prone to play around the perimeter more. Maybe he needs a better C or smarter line mates, but he seems to be stagnant.
OJ is not even close. This has been discussed over and over again and if you want the truth about his development...got to the prospect thread and read the comments from Utica fans, they give a less-biased review than any Canuck fans.
So... Demko just got back from a concussion, I know. He is the closest we got...Hughes very hopeful, but not guarantee against professional players. We have 2 prospects that have potential, not enough for me to even say we're "not bad"... and considering it's been 5 years, we are in an awful state.