Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
or had an ok playoffs with two really good games.
Draisaitl? That's BS.
or had an ok playoffs with two really good games.
Read what you want to read, I guess.So they're career numbers aren't almost the same? No need to put down other players just to try and justify Drai's contact. Drai had a great season playing on McDavid's wing. No one is saying he didn't. Yet Pastrnak had a better season not playing with a McDavid. Like I said, two great young players.
Drai also dominated the playoffs when McDavid was failing somewhat to produce.
So what are the future implications of this deal one/two years from now? Barring a major leap in the Canadian dollar, I would imagine that both Maroon and Nuge are goners and both Nurse and Benning are going to get bridge-dealed hard when their deals expire. I see this contract as purely the Current cost of doing business but given dollars tied up in an immovable Lucic plus difficult to move deals for Russell and Sekera, the negative consequences are somewhat inevitable. Its a shame. I love Nuge and the Big Rig and I sincerely hoped we'd have a chance of retaining them.
McDavid had the best defensive players in the world boat anchored to him the entire time, and Draisaitl was also largely unproductive when on that line.
You really shouldn't be basing your entire thesis off a sample like that, anyway. There have been MANY players who have had great stretches or great playoffs who weren't going to maintain that.
I consider his 2nd season as successfulDarisaitl has had 1 successful season. He managed to hit it out of the park last year but its still 1 season. 1 season playing with the best player in the world BTW.
So no...I do not think that justifys $8.5M over 8 years. Its an over pay IMO by at least $1M per year.
Now we have $21M tied up for the next 8 years and we have to hope like hell that this wasnt a one off year for Leon. You cant base 8 years of contract on 1 season...its a bad risk IMO.
Agreed.
Bad contract.
$21M for the next 8 years for 2 players. One of which (Draisaitl) has only had 1 successful season. This is a fail IMO.
People gleefully ran Eberle out of town based on it.
The two groups are really "people who can't know for sure, but some are more optimistic than others".
The WOWY is at the centre of all of this. How can it not concern you that Draisaitl was nowhere near as productive without McDavid, but McDavid was pretty much AS good with or without him?
Question, do you see Draisaitl as a player who can be expect play at, or better then, the level of last season going forward?
I'm not trying to glib, I'm curious how you see it.
Draisaitl dominated a round of the playoffs (including a 5 point game in a blowout).
People seem to forget that the first 4 games of the San Jose series he was MIA. Hell, I remember a few people around here who wanted to bench him in that series before he started getting going.
Drai just set the market for second contracts for players who have only had one good season (an excellent one in his case).
If Pastrnak and Eichel's agents were smart they would only use Drai's as a comp as it set the floor for theirs and others moving forward. Chia just changed the market for 2nd contracts moving forward, much like Lowe and co did with Hall, Ebs and Nuge.
I was unsure of how Draisaitl would do without having Hall on his line, but he still managed to play at a high level without him. Sure, he got a lot of production due to playing with Connor last season, but that's not a big problem imo. Players like Hall, Eberle, and Lucic failed on doing so. The real questions remains about Drasaitl is how he'll be able to drive his own line without McDavid next season, and who are those two specific linemates on his wing going to be?
Read what you want to read, I guess.
I didn't put down either player or say they weren't similar. You were the one that did so by saying Draisaitl has had one good season when that's simply not true, and the only good season you say he had was because he was playing with McDavid.
Pastrnak wasn't exactly playing with crap players in Boston this past season.
I honestly dont know...that IMO is the problem.
I need to see more. No matter how much I like Draisaitl (and I really do like the player) I cant structure an opinion with out more information.
No matter how much I am a fan of this player the reality is he has only had 1 successful season AND it was playing with or beside the best player on the planet.
I just needed to see more.
1 season. Thats right....1 season.
So what are the future implications of this deal one/two years from now? Barring a major leap in the Canadian dollar, I would imagine that both Maroon and Nuge are goners and both Nurse and Benning are going to get bridge-dealed hard when their deals expire. I see this contract as purely the Current cost of doing business but given dollars tied up in an immovable Lucic plus difficult to move deals for Russell and Sekera, the negative consequences are somewhat inevitable. Its a shame. I love Nuge and the Big Rig and I sincerely hoped we'd have a chance of retaining them.
People gleefully ran Eberle out of town based on it.
Chia did set (inflate greatly) the market here but Skinner and Tavares were the trend setting contracts back then, not the Oilers kids.
The important thing here, as always is the case with the Oilers, is to focus on the negative.
I'm not upset or pretending that playing with McDavid didn't help. I was disagreeing with your comment that Draisaitl had only one good season before his extension.Quick edit
Marchand went from a 50 point player to almost winning the Art Ross with Pastrnak as his linemate. Bergeron is an elite defensive center but doesn't come close to comparing to McDavid offensively. I never said he only had his one good season because he was playing with McDavid, but to think it didn't help or inflate his numbers a bit is silly talk.
Not sure why you're so upset that I said Pastrnak's agent should be using Drai's as a comparison.