Updated list on the call up/scrub evaluation.
Carrick - Reminds me more of a better David Warsofsky and the RFA guy you don't tender an offer to the next year. Not really a scrub, but we have enough of his kind here.
McLeod - Nothing great right now. Better than Kevin Rooney, maybe better than Seney right now, maybe not. Not an NHL player yet.
Bastian - He gets an I for incomplete. Haven't seen enough yet.
Agostino - Good player for the 4th line going forward.
Tangradi - Rich man's Tim Sestito. Not an NHL player.
Pietila - Good penalty killer, but he's not, has never been and never will be an NHL player
Yakovlev - He's okay, better than Santini, but nothing great. I could do with or without him. I'm more open to giving him another chance than Carrick, because we haven't seen enough of him at the NHL level like Carrick has seen over the last several years, but we have enough of his kind and better here.
Blackwood - Was overachieving a bit. Not having the best game. Still had a better stretch of 15 or so games than either of the other two goalies that have played here this year.
Lappin - See Pietila and Tangradi. Probably a little better than them, not by much. I'd like to see us move on and let him walk in UFA, so the call ups to him stop for good.
Noesen - Agree with the most regression trophy award. Loved him last year. He'll be off the team after this year. He'll be one of this offseason's Beau Bennett's/DSP's.
Rooney - Rod Pelley 2.0. He can kill penalties, he tries hard and he can score once in a while (even Hot Rod had 9 career goals, but never 4 in a season). Other than that? He's useless. You can do better than him on your 4th line or even 13th or 14th forward. You have to do better if you wanna be a good team and we had exactly 0 forwards as bad as him on a full time basis last year when we were in the playoffs.
Gabriel - Goons need to be out of the NHL, unless they can actually play. This one can't.
Quenneville - Get lost. On waivers or something. The most disappointing out of any call up this year, because nobody expects anything from Tangradi, Pietila, Lappin, Rooney or Gabriel. So while I wouldn't say he's the worst call up this year, he's definitely the most disappointing by far.