Toews2Bickell
It's Showtime
- Nov 24, 2013
- 23,393
- 23,306
Leaf fans are more down on Willy than ever so you'll probably have some takers on this. Joker is great but I'll keep Willy and expect him to bounce back fully next season. If after that he is still not effective for us then I consider moving him. The last ~40 games or so he scored slightly above his career PPG and during that whole stretch he couldn't buy a goal. I just have too much faith in him to be great to let him go after 1 bad season.Chicago: William Nylander
Toronto: Henri Jokiharhu
Fair?
I think Chicago probably has to add something pretty significant here.
Not the 3rd OVR pick, not Debrincat.Define significant?
Teams don't move 19 year old 30 point Dmen for 7 million dollar 40 point buttersoft wingers
Define significant?
So you basically are asking for Joker and Boqvist? LOL, that's ridiculous.Probably at least another piece equal to or greater in value to Jokiharju. Nylander had a rough season, but his underlying numbers are still excellent and he has enough of resume in his short career for that to not effect his value much. Jokiharju is nice, but this is a clear sell-low on Nylander.
To be fair, I believe he's not a Leaf fan per se but at least has a level head about Nylander's value. I do not think anyone believes that Nylander is worth Joker + Boqvist. I listed a 1 for 1 trade willy for boqvist and then I gave 2 reasonable alternatives if you don't want to include Boqvist.So you basically are asking for Joker and Boqvist? LOL, that's ridiculous.
Teams don't move 19 year old 30 point Dmen for 7 million dollar 40 point buttersoft wingers
Teams don't move 19 year old 30 point Dmen for 7 million dollar 40 point buttersoft wingers
I wouldn't pay Boqvist for Nylander right now, so I don't think if he had a better season that he would suddenly be worth the both of them. I think Joker is close to fair value, with a little add from Chicago, like Perlini, or Kahun.To be fair, I believe he's not a Leaf fan per se but at least has a level head about Nylander's value. I do not think anyone believes that Nylander is worth Joker + Boqvist. I listed a 1 for 1 trade willy for boqvist and then I gave 2 reasonable alternatives if you don't want to include Boqvist.
Joker + Boqvist would be worth Nylander if Nylander just put up a PPG season while maintaining his underlying stats but that's not the case. At least not yet. Although in the future this statement could be 100% wrong
So you basically are asking for Joker and Boqvist? LOL, that's ridiculous.
You are out to lunch.Teams don't move 19 year old 30 point Dmen for 7 million dollar 40 point buttersoft wingers
I wouldn't pay Boqvist for Nylander right now, so I don't think if he had a better season that he would suddenly be worth the both of them. I think Joker is close to fair value, with a little add from Chicago, like Perlini, or Kahun.
To be fair when I posted above I stated that I said that for Nylander for Boqvist most CHI fans don't want.I wouldn't pay Boqvist for Nylander right now, so I don't think if he had a better season that he would suddenly be worth the both of them. I think Joker is close to fair value, with a little add from Chicago, like Perlini, or Kahun.
You're becoming my favourite non-leafs fanIts not.
You're looking at this through bias. Nylander had 2.5 years of really good hockey before this season and Joker has had 1/2 a year of hockey in the NHL? He doesn't have the potential of a guarenteed top 4 guy with the upside of a #2 (as it stands right now) so I'd stick with Willy as will most fans. Even the haters and there's a lot of Willy haters.It is.
Nylander is not a 40 point winger. But I hope Dubas thinks he is and Stan makes the call...
It is.
That's true, he did only have 27 points last year, good point
That's true, he did only have 27 points last year, good point
T2B - you couldn't leave well enough alone, couldn't resist could you??? lol..
fine, we will add Seabrook, sign right here ___________X