Brady Tkachuk Vs Nick Suzuki

[a mangy Meowth]

Habs fans embarrassing themselves just a bit in here IMO


These players are very close.

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

Tkachuk is more proven. Suzuki playing a more important position makes it closer than what it normally is, but it's Tkachuk easily.

 

[ole ole]

Habs fans embarrassing themselves just a bit in here IMO


These players are very close.

HF fans embarrassing themselves just a bit in here IMO. Yes ,These players are very close right now.

 

[a mangy Meowth]

HF fans embarrassing themselves just a bit in here IMO. Yes ,These players are very close right now.

As a neutral fan I observed it as being almost entirely Habs fans doing this behavior. I don't care about the Habs or Sens BTW

 

[ole ole]

As a neutral fan I observed it as being almost entirely Habs fans doing this behavior. I don't care about the Habs or Sens BTW

Your supposedly a neutral but claiming almost entirely Habs fans doing this behavior.Your Veil is showing.
Go back and re-check the posts. Most making ridiculous statements or claiming it's easily Tkachuk are Non-Hab fans.

 

[a mangy Meowth]

Your supposedly a neutral but claiming almost entirely Habs fans doing this behavior.Your Veil is showing.
Go back and re-check the posts. Most making ridiculous statements or claiming it's easily Tkachuk are Non-Hab fans.

You're a habs fan, why am I not surprised you're offended by what I said?

 

[ole ole]

You're a habs fan, why am I not surprised you're offended by what I said?

Not offended just showing the stuff you said can be proven wrong just by going through this thread and than you claim to be impartial which is complete BS.

 

[Pyrophorus]

I think its Suzuki, if fact he (not Caufield) might become the best player on the Habs, and very formidable player in the league.

Brady is made to tip pucks in, after shots from Chabot.

 

[a mangy Meowth]

Not offended just showing the stuff you said can be proven wrong just by going through this thread and than you claim to be impartial which is complete BS.

How am I not impartial? I'm an Avalanche fan who doesn't give a shit about the sens or habs lmao

 

[Pitaya]

Suzuki definitely has the higher ceiling. He has ppg potential, which tkachuk doesnt

Not according to this poll or draft scouts

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Not according to this poll or draft scouts

The poll isn't asking who has the higher potential. It's asking who is the current better player.

By draft scouts, you mean the draft rankings? Players don't get drafted just based on their potential. Ryan Merkley was easily top 10 in potential but got drafted 21st since he also had more bust factors than those who went ahead of him.

 

[Pitaya]

The poll isn't asking who has the higher potential. It's asking who is the current better player.

By draft scouts, you mean the draft rankings? Players don't get drafted just based on their potential. Ryan Merkley was easily top 10 in potential but got drafted 21st since he also had more bust factors than those who went ahead of him.

Okay but Tkachuk was drafted higher and did what Suzuki did a year younger on a worse team

So im confused exactly how Suzuki has 'clearly higher potential' according to some in here?

 

[The Great Weal]

Okay but Tkachuk was drafted higher and did what Suzuki did a year younger on a worse team

So im confused exactly how Suzuki has 'clearly higher potential' according to some in here?

It's actually 5 weeks younger...

 

[Pitaya]

It's actually 5 weeks younger...

I meant Tkachuk had as good a season Suzuki had this year, last year

So a year younger when he had an equivalent rookie year to Suzuki this year

 

[The Great Weal]

I meant Tkachuk had as good a season Suzuki had this year, last year

So a year younger when he had an equivalent rookie year to Suzuki this year

He also had as good a season as Suzuki this year. Not surprised you ignored that.

 

[Pitaya]

He also had as good a season as Suzuki this year. Not surprised you ignored that.

How is that a bad thing exactly?

 

[The Great Weal]

How is that a bad thing exactly?

It isn't, but they had a very similar season this year and are only 5 weeks apart. The age argument is not a good one.

 

[Big Empty]

Suzuki is so much better. This poll will look silly in about a year. Did you guys watch him in the playoffs? Just listen to the Flyers players talk about him.

It’s not even close for me.

Well… I don’t think I was wrong

 

[King Karl]

Well… I don’t think I was wrong

Nice necro. No question that Suzuki was very good in the playoffs and his stock has risen quite a bit. Tkachuk is still better though.

 

[Big Empty]

Nice necro. No question that Suzuki was very good in the playoffs and his stock has risen quite a bit. Tkachuk is still better though.

Tkachuk is not better and I wouldn’t consider this a crazy bump.

Someone liked my post today and I remembered the take. I said in a year the poll would look silly and it clearly does.

Suzuki is on another level.

 

[Xspyrit]

Not really 2 players you can compare. Both are very impactful players, Tkachuk for everything that he brings, Suzuki for being a smart 2-way center.

If both were traded for each other, it would add a pretty big piece on each team while creating a massive hole at the same time.

 

[Rockomax]

Not really 2 players you can compare. Both are very impactful players, Tkachuk for everything that he brings, Suzuki for being a smart 2-way center.

If both were traded for each other, it would add a pretty big piece on each team while creating a massive hole at the same time.

This, probably, as much as I hate to say.

 

[Xspyrit]

This, probably, as much as I hate to say.

Stutzle-Suzuki-Batherson
Formenton-Norris-Brown
Paul-Brown-Dadonov
Watson-Pinto-White

Forward group would still look promising

Because of Suzuki being Montreal's best center, maybe they couldn't afford it as much

Tkachuk-Caufield and Toffoli-Gallagher as your top-6 wingers would be quite interesting

 

[King Karl]

Tkachuk is not better and I wouldn’t consider this a crazy bump.

Someone liked my post today and I remembered the take. I said in a year the poll would look silly and it clearly does.

Suzuki is on another level.

Ah okay well then you're cleared of all necro charges. If you'd asked this question before the playoffs I'd imagine you'd get a similar response. Obviously player A vs B is almost always subjective, but I don't really see how a good playoff run changes anything. Tkachuk hasn't been playing for the past couple months, Suzuki has - you've obviously going to get a bunch of recency bias.

 

[JungleBeat]

- C > LW
- Better offensive skill set and potential
- 200 ft game

Sadly, I’ll have to say that Suzuki is better.