alfstheman
Registered User
- Jul 2, 2009
- 764
- 316
10 times out of 10 if teams had the option to take either Phaneuf or Ryan teams would take Phaneuf. Phaneuf is still still a good defenseman just not top 4 anymore. He is way more reliable season in and season out than Ryan is. LA is also the worst team in the league. That's not because of Phaneuf as a bottom pairing D. He at least leads the team in hits.
Really tho? If Ryan continues this play all season (doubtful but you never know) and plays well next season I could see a contender take a chance next deadline if Ottawa retains.
Phaneuf is a 7 mill bottom pair D, Ryan is a 7 mill pp specialist who is playing like a decent 2nd liner atm.
Also as we all know too well, leading the team in hits doesnt make you a good defenseman...