Player Discussion Bobby Ryan Part VII

Status
Not open for further replies.

Samsquanch

Raging Bull Squatch
Nov 28, 2008
8,227
4,971
Sudbury
Its been obvious for years (to me at least) that Bobby is built for the PP at this point, and if we have any hope of him being a useful player for us, this will be it.

The guy can barely skate, but he's strong along the boards, long reach and stick, and has great vision. Happy to see it paying off for us and him.
 

BonHoonLayneCornell

Registered User
Oct 16, 2006
15,388
10,593
Yukon
I thought he looked pretty decent to start the year last year too playing alongside Brassard, but then the injuries came.

Would be nice to see him have a healthy year for once.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xspyrit

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
30,856
9,793
Montreal, Canada
I am fully attentive during the games, and still want him off the roster.

Disagree if you wish

If you are implying one solid game should change my opinion than give your head a shake

If you are fully attentive, then why did you come up with "Get him the hell off this team" after the last game where he was probably our best forward and had the best underlying stats on the team? (facts + eye test)

You have the right to want him off the roster but the timing for this was weird after a really strong game...

Alex Chiasson = 2 Goals

Bobby Ryan = 1 Goal

Alex Chiasson 3 goals

Alex Wennberg 0 goal
Ondrej Palat 0
Loui Eriksson 0 goal
Casey Mittelstadt 0 goal
Jesperi Kotkaniemi 0 goal
Nino Niederreiter 0 goal
Michael Grabner 0 goal
Vladislav Namestnikov 0 goal
J.T. Brown 0 goal
Anthony Beauvillier 0 goal
Taylor Hall 1 goal
Teuvo Teravainen 1 goal
Matt Duchene 1 goal
Mathew Barzal 1 goal
Nazem Kadri 1 goal
etc

Hence Chiasson is better than all these players.

I get the NHL has become more reliant on skating but I'm surprised how enamoured people are with skating. It's the number 2 reason he gets flak and while I agree it is something that holds him back individually it isn't something that prevents him from contributing to the team. He makes a lot of small plays that support his linemates and they usually get over looked because they don't wow you. He's very much the opposite of Ryan Dzingel but a similar caliber of player but because one can skate fast and draw your attention for a couple of seconds he is nearly immune to any criticism.

Good point, sometimes it looks like fast = good for many hockey fans. If Ryan had Dzingel skating, he would still be a huge star in this league. Like you said, in general Ryan makes several more positive plays per game than Dzingel but one gets absolutely blasted, while the other is fine because age, skating and money. Anyway, coaches and analysts/people from the hockey world know at least.

I remember looking at the data in Boucher's first year here. Ryan's drop in productivity was almost fully the result of change in utilization. decreased ice, decreased 1 pp time....actually almost non existent 1 pp time.

it's early. the pp looks great and Ryan is contributing on it

Yes. Makes me want to look at the data.

First 3 years in Ottawa (from 2013-14 to 2015-16), among the 400 forwards who played at least 1000 minutes at ES, Ryan was 47th in P/60 (points per 60 minutes played). Note that Duchene was 12th, Stone was 20th and Hoffman was 23rd. And it's not because of "secondary assists", Ryan was also 48th in P1/60 (primary points)

But he was not a PP specialist at all, as he was 110th in P/60 on the PP during the same period of time (among 189 forwards who played at least 300 minutes on the PP)

Now let's look at 2016-17 :

219th in P/60 out of 353 forwards who played more than 500 minutes at ES, wasn't very luck with secondary assists I guess because he was 188th in P1/60. Not that it matters because he had a terrible regular season anyway, although it's quite understandable as he lost his mother from cancer in the summer and just had his first born child, plus he had to deal with many injuries while trying to adjust to Guy Boucher system. Plus, team PP was awful. We know what happened in the playoffs though, he more than redeemed himself.

Still not a PP specialist at all, 186th in P/60 among 199 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. Brassard was just a little better but Dzingel and Smith were even worse. It has more to do with a terrible team PP.

And 2017-18 :

He was 72nd in P/60 among 353 forwards who played 500 minutes at ES. :amazed:

lol don't let the haters see that. He was 3rd on the Sens behind only Stone and Duchene (and yes more than Karlsson who is a D-man though). I found he was actually quite decent last year and rebounding from a bad regular season, although injuries ruined him again.

But again, not a great PP production as he was 198th in P/60 among 212 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. But the Sens PP was really bad again.

There is age, there is injuries but I also think he got absolutely shafted under Boucher. He didn't really play with a lot of talent too" He played mainly with Dzingel and Turris in 2016-17 + a bit with Smith and Brassard. It was better in 2017-18, as he played mostly with Duchene, then Hoffman, Dzingel, Stone, Brassard and Pageau. That's probably a reason why he was producing better.

Still a bit early to look at 2018-19 as sample sizes are small but the PP is finally looking great like you said and if Ryan produces on the PP and plays with more talent at ES (Duchene, Stone, Tkachuk, maybe even Tierney), I can easily see him bounce back to a 50+ pts season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ice-Tray and JD1

JD1

Registered User
Sep 12, 2005
16,130
9,701
If you are fully attentive, then why did you come up with "Get him the hell off this team" after the last game where he was probably our best forward and had the best underlying stats on the team? (facts + eye test)

You have the right to want him off the roster but the timing for this was weird after a really strong game...



Alex Chiasson 3 goals

Alex Wennberg 0 goal
Ondrej Palat 0
Loui Eriksson 0 goal
Casey Mittelstadt 0 goal
Jesperi Kotkaniemi 0 goal
Nino Niederreiter 0 goal
Michael Grabner 0 goal
Vladislav Namestnikov 0 goal
J.T. Brown 0 goal
Anthony Beauvillier 0 goal
Taylor Hall 1 goal
Teuvo Teravainen 1 goal
Matt Duchene 1 goal
Mathew Barzal 1 goal
Nazem Kadri 1 goal
etc

Hence Chiasson is better than all these players.



Good point, sometimes it looks like fast = good for many hockey fans. If Ryan had Dzingel skating, he would still be a huge star in this league. Like you said, in general Ryan makes several more positive plays per game than Dzingel but one gets absolutely blasted, while the other is fine because age, skating and money. Anyway, coaches and analysts/people from the hockey world know at least.



Yes. Makes me want to look at the data.

First 3 years in Ottawa (from 2013-14 to 2015-16), among the 400 forwards who played at least 1000 minutes at ES, Ryan was 47th in P/60 (points per 60 minutes played). Note that Duchene was 12th, Stone was 20th and Hoffman was 23rd. And it's not because of "secondary assists", Ryan was also 48th in P1/60 (primary points)

But he was not a PP specialist at all, as he was 110th in P/60 on the PP during the same period of time (among 189 forwards who played at least 300 minutes on the PP)

Now let's look at 2016-17 :

219th in P/60 out of 353 forwards who played more than 500 minutes at ES, wasn't very luck with secondary assists I guess because he was 188th in P1/60. Not that it matters because he had a terrible regular season anyway, although it's quite understandable as he lost his mother from cancer in the summer and just had his first born child, plus he had to deal with many injuries while trying to adjust to Guy Boucher system. Plus, team PP was awful. We know what happened in the playoffs though, he more than redeemed himself.

Still not a PP specialist at all, 186th in P/60 among 199 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. Brassard was just a little better but Dzingel and Smith were even worse. It has more to do with a terrible team PP.

And 2017-18 :

He was 72nd in P/60 among 353 forwards who played 500 minutes at ES. :amazed:

lol don't let the haters see that. He was 3rd on the Sens behind only Stone and Duchene (and yes more than Karlsson who is a D-man though). I found he was actually quite decent last year and rebounding from a bad regular season, although injuries ruined him again.

But again, not a great PP production as he was 198th in P/60 among 212 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. But the Sens PP was really bad again.

There is age, there is injuries but I also think he got absolutely shafted under Boucher. He didn't really play with a lot of talent too" He played mainly with Dzingel and Turris in 2016-17 + a bit with Smith and Brassard. It was better in 2017-18, as he played mostly with Duchene, then Hoffman, Dzingel, Stone, Brassard and Pageau. That's probably a reason why he was producing better.

Still a bit early to look at 2018-19 as sample sizes are small but the PP is finally looking great like you said and if Ryan produces on the PP and plays with more talent at ES (Duchene, Stone, Tkachuk, maybe even Tierney), I can easily see him bounce back to a 50+ pts season.

a lot of quality information there on ryan. kudos for putting it together. he takes a lot of flak here. it's pretty simple to see the utilization change and it's also pretty simple to see the skill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xspyrit

Liver King

Registered User
Jan 23, 2016
7,430
5,266
If you are fully attentive, then why did you come up with "Get him the hell off this team" after the last game where he was probably our best forward and had the best underlying stats on the team? (facts + eye test)

You have the right to want him off the roster but the timing for this was weird after a really strong game...



Alex Chiasson 3 goals

Alex Wennberg 0 goal
Ondrej Palat 0
Loui Eriksson 0 goal
Casey Mittelstadt 0 goal
Jesperi Kotkaniemi 0 goal
Nino Niederreiter 0 goal
Michael Grabner 0 goal
Vladislav Namestnikov 0 goal
J.T. Brown 0 goal
Anthony Beauvillier 0 goal
Taylor Hall 1 goal
Teuvo Teravainen 1 goal
Matt Duchene 1 goal
Mathew Barzal 1 goal
Nazem Kadri 1 goal
etc

Hence Chiasson is better than all these players.



Good point, sometimes it looks like fast = good for many hockey fans. If Ryan had Dzingel skating, he would still be a huge star in this league. Like you said, in general Ryan makes several more positive plays per game than Dzingel but one gets absolutely blasted, while the other is fine because age, skating and money. Anyway, coaches and analysts/people from the hockey world know at least.



Yes. Makes me want to look at the data.

First 3 years in Ottawa (from 2013-14 to 2015-16), among the 400 forwards who played at least 1000 minutes at ES, Ryan was 47th in P/60 (points per 60 minutes played). Note that Duchene was 12th, Stone was 20th and Hoffman was 23rd. And it's not because of "secondary assists", Ryan was also 48th in P1/60 (primary points)

But he was not a PP specialist at all, as he was 110th in P/60 on the PP during the same period of time (among 189 forwards who played at least 300 minutes on the PP)

Now let's look at 2016-17 :

219th in P/60 out of 353 forwards who played more than 500 minutes at ES, wasn't very luck with secondary assists I guess because he was 188th in P1/60. Not that it matters because he had a terrible regular season anyway, although it's quite understandable as he lost his mother from cancer in the summer and just had his first born child, plus he had to deal with many injuries while trying to adjust to Guy Boucher system. Plus, team PP was awful. We know what happened in the playoffs though, he more than redeemed himself.

Still not a PP specialist at all, 186th in P/60 among 199 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. Brassard was just a little better but Dzingel and Smith were even worse. It has more to do with a terrible team PP.

And 2017-18 :

He was 72nd in P/60 among 353 forwards who played 500 minutes at ES. :amazed:

lol don't let the haters see that. He was 3rd on the Sens behind only Stone and Duchene (and yes more than Karlsson who is a D-man though). I found he was actually quite decent last year and rebounding from a bad regular season, although injuries ruined him again.

But again, not a great PP production as he was 198th in P/60 among 212 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. But the Sens PP was really bad again.

There is age, there is injuries but I also think he got absolutely shafted under Boucher. He didn't really play with a lot of talent too" He played mainly with Dzingel and Turris in 2016-17 + a bit with Smith and Brassard. It was better in 2017-18, as he played mostly with Duchene, then Hoffman, Dzingel, Stone, Brassard and Pageau. That's probably a reason why he was producing better.

Still a bit early to look at 2018-19 as sample sizes are small but the PP is finally looking great like you said and if Ryan produces on the PP and plays with more talent at ES (Duchene, Stone, Tkachuk, maybe even Tierney), I can easily see him bounce back to a 50+ pts season.

GET BOBBY RYAN THE HELL OFF THIS TEAM
 
  • Like
Reactions: Senscore

Tuna99

Registered User
Sep 26, 2009
14,926
6,982
If you are fully attentive, then why did you come up with "Get him the hell off this team" after the last game where he was probably our best forward and had the best underlying stats on the team? (facts + eye test)

You have the right to want him off the roster but the timing for this was weird after a really strong game...



Alex Chiasson 3 goals

Alex Wennberg 0 goal
Ondrej Palat 0
Loui Eriksson 0 goal
Casey Mittelstadt 0 goal
Jesperi Kotkaniemi 0 goal
Nino Niederreiter 0 goal
Michael Grabner 0 goal
Vladislav Namestnikov 0 goal
J.T. Brown 0 goal
Anthony Beauvillier 0 goal
Taylor Hall 1 goal
Teuvo Teravainen 1 goal
Matt Duchene 1 goal
Mathew Barzal 1 goal
Nazem Kadri 1 goal
etc

Hence Chiasson is better than all these players.



Good point, sometimes it looks like fast = good for many hockey fans. If Ryan had Dzingel skating, he would still be a huge star in this league. Like you said, in general Ryan makes several more positive plays per game than Dzingel but one gets absolutely blasted, while the other is fine because age, skating and money. Anyway, coaches and analysts/people from the hockey world know at least.



Yes. Makes me want to look at the data.

First 3 years in Ottawa (from 2013-14 to 2015-16), among the 400 forwards who played at least 1000 minutes at ES, Ryan was 47th in P/60 (points per 60 minutes played). Note that Duchene was 12th, Stone was 20th and Hoffman was 23rd. And it's not because of "secondary assists", Ryan was also 48th in P1/60 (primary points)

But he was not a PP specialist at all, as he was 110th in P/60 on the PP during the same period of time (among 189 forwards who played at least 300 minutes on the PP)

Now let's look at 2016-17 :

219th in P/60 out of 353 forwards who played more than 500 minutes at ES, wasn't very luck with secondary assists I guess because he was 188th in P1/60. Not that it matters because he had a terrible regular season anyway, although it's quite understandable as he lost his mother from cancer in the summer and just had his first born child, plus he had to deal with many injuries while trying to adjust to Guy Boucher system. Plus, team PP was awful. We know what happened in the playoffs though, he more than redeemed himself.

Still not a PP specialist at all, 186th in P/60 among 199 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. Brassard was just a little better but Dzingel and Smith were even worse. It has more to do with a terrible team PP.

And 2017-18 :

He was 72nd in P/60 among 353 forwards who played 500 minutes at ES. :amazed:

lol don't let the haters see that. He was 3rd on the Sens behind only Stone and Duchene (and yes more than Karlsson who is a D-man though). I found he was actually quite decent last year and rebounding from a bad regular season, although injuries ruined him again.

But again, not a great PP production as he was 198th in P/60 among 212 forwards who played at least 100 minutes on the PP. But the Sens PP was really bad again.

There is age, there is injuries but I also think he got absolutely shafted under Boucher. He didn't really play with a lot of talent too" He played mainly with Dzingel and Turris in 2016-17 + a bit with Smith and Brassard. It was better in 2017-18, as he played mostly with Duchene, then Hoffman, Dzingel, Stone, Brassard and Pageau. That's probably a reason why he was producing better.

Still a bit early to look at 2018-19 as sample sizes are small but the PP is finally looking great like you said and if Ryan produces on the PP and plays with more talent at ES (Duchene, Stone, Tkachuk, maybe even Tierney), I can easily see him bounce back to a 50+ pts season.

I just find he never shows up when you need him, he never ever ever has games where he’s our best player, he isn’t a player that creates momentum, he makes a lot of lazy plays that look like effort because he’s usually falling or getting spun around.

I literally can’t think of 1 single game in his entire time here where Ryan was just simply our best player like other top players do on the odd night like Stone, Duchesne, Chabot, Pageau, Dzingel, Tkachuk have.

I’ll actually say Tkachuk has played more impactful games since he’s been in Ottawa then Ryan has since he’s been in Ottawa
 

Icelevel

During these difficult times...
Sep 9, 2009
24,825
5,022
I just find he never shows up when you need him, he never ever ever has games where he’s our best player, he isn’t a player that creates momentum, he makes a lot of lazy plays that look like effort because he’s usually falling or getting spun around.

I literally can’t think of 1 single game in his entire time here where Ryan was just simply our best player like other top players do on the odd night like Stone, Duchesne, Chabot, Pageau, Dzingel, Tkachuk have.

I’ll actually say Tkachuk has played more impactful games since he’s been in Ottawa then Ryan has since he’s been in Ottawa
He was very good in the playoffs.
 

RAFI BOMB

Registered User
May 11, 2016
7,389
7,646
Brian Burke had it right all the way back in 2014:
“He is not intense. That word is not in his vocabulary,” Burke said during one meeting, as quoted by ESPN.com. “It’s never going to be in his vocabulary. He can’t spell intense.” Brian Burke on Bobby Ryan’s exclusion from U.S. Olympic team: ‘He can’t spell intense’ | The Star

Bobby Ryan has been terrible every game this year and looks a lot worse than last year. He needs to be off this team. he doesn't fit the play style and he doesn't really contribute anything each game. Either trade him for a bad contract like Backes or Lucic or waive him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: InAbsensia

ReginKarlssonLehner

Let's Win It All
May 3, 2010
40,765
11,060
Dubai Marina
Its been obvious for years (to me at least) that Bobby is built for the PP at this point, and if we have any hope of him being a useful player for us, this will be it.

The guy can barely skate, but he's strong along the boards, long reach and stick, and has great vision. Happy to see it paying off for us and him.

WHAT
 

bert

Registered User
Nov 11, 2002
36,144
22,116
Visit site
I love bobby as a guy but tonight was a really tough look for him. Its pretty insane he makes more money than MacKinnon lol.
 

Stylizer1

SENSimillanaire
Jun 12, 2009
19,296
3,695
Ottabot City
What? Bobby is kinda fat and can plant himself like a tree to close off gaps along the boards.
Timberrrrrrrrrr

cropped_RYAN.gif
 

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
30,856
9,793
Montreal, Canada
GET BOBBY RYAN THE HELL OFF THIS TEAM

Ok you hate him and?

Do you really think Bobby Ryan is "holding this team back"? :laugh: Or that it would be better to have another non NHL ready super fast player ala Formenton instead? I'm pretty sure in your mind that Formenton has been better. But that's the thing I was talking about with JD1, a player skating fast is pretty much automatically better than a slower skater in some fans mind, even though all underlying stats suggest the opposite. I would even say that playing a lot with Formenton, Paajarvi and Smith has been holding Ryan back. It's hard to expect anybody to put numbers with those unless maybe you're elite like Stone.

Back to the point of Ryan "holding the team back", do you realize that we just traded a future HOF D-man for a bottom pairing D-man, a forward who has been a bottom-6 forward until now and a few good futures? Brassard was also traded for futures, Hoffman was traded for a cheaper but less productive player, Phaneuf traded for a LTIR contract... Why even get mad? This team is not supposed to compete at all. Bobby Ryan has become a stop gap for this team. There's no point to trade him right now because you'd have to take back another overpaid player in return. Don't think people would be happier to have Backes, Phaneuf, Abdelkader, Callahan, Lehtera, Bonino, Shaw, Neal, Lucic, Eriksson, Laad, Seabrook, etc

Don't worry, I would like to see him "off this team" as well so I wouldn't have to read all the Ryan bashing anymore or just so Melnyk can put more money in this pocket (I guess it's a positive?) but unless Dorion get creative like in the Phaneuf deal, I don't see it happening for now.

I just find he never shows up when you need him, he never ever ever has games where he’s our best player, he isn’t a player that creates momentum, he makes a lot of lazy plays that look like effort because he’s usually falling or getting spun around.

I’ll actually say Tkachuk has played more impactful games since he’s been in Ottawa then Ryan has since he’s been in Ottawa

He never shows up when you need him? You know that playoff run was just over a year ago, and yes there was some games even in the last 2 years that Ryan was our best player (see below), or at least one of the best. But it shouldn't happen much, when you have Karlsson, Stone, Duchene, Chabot, etc. That boat has sailed with age and injuries.

I literally can’t think of 1 single game in his entire time here where Ryan was just simply our best player like other top players do on the odd night like Stone, Duchesne, Chabot, Pageau, Dzingel, Tkachuk have.

I’ll actually say Tkachuk has played more impactful games since he’s been in Ottawa then Ryan has since he’s been in Ottawa

:laugh: I love Tkachuk and no doubt in my mind he is going to be an impact player, maybe even on Stone level, but that's just silly. You clearly don't remember Ryan from 2013 to 2016 or even the 2017 playoffs. Just 2017-18 and even 2016-17, I found a few games where he was in the three stars of the game (there's probably more but won't check them all)

Islanders vs. Senators - Game Summary - March 27, 2018 - ESPN
Rangers vs. Senators - Game Summary - December 13, 2017 - ESPN
Ducks vs. Senators - Game Summary - February 1, 2018 - ESPN
Sabres vs. Senators - Game Summary - February 14, 2017 - ESPN
Senators vs. Blackhawks - Game Summary - December 20, 2016 - ESPN
Bruins vs. Senators - Game Summary - April 12, 2017 - ESPN
 
Last edited:

Burrowsaurus

Registered User
Mar 20, 2013
42,447
16,066
I just find he never shows up when you need him, he never ever ever has games where he’s our best player, he isn’t a player that creates momentum, he makes a lot of lazy plays that look like effort because he’s usually falling or getting spun around.

I literally can’t think of 1 single game in his entire time here where Ryan was just simply our best player like other top players do on the odd night like Stone, Duchesne, Chabot, Pageau, Dzingel, Tkachuk have.

I’ll actually say Tkachuk has played more impactful games since he’s been in Ottawa then Ryan has since he’s been in Ottawa
Dude cmon lol. Remember Bobby in his first half season here? He was f***ing awesome. Then he got hurt and never regained that form again until 16-17 playoffs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad