Time for me to grieve a bit.
I'll keep this to this series and other posts to relevant threads.
On the Seattle side...Seattle was the better team in this series. Their depth and speed just gave the Avs absolute fits. Their system was ultra aggressive on the puck relenting no space to the Avs... and they had the skating to execute on it. I've never been a Hakstol fan, but he coached his ass off in this series. Seattle was more prepared and just punched the Avs in the mouth... to where it turned out the Avs didn't have anybody to punch back beyond the top line. Grubauer was spectacular in this series. I expect this comment to get some hate, but he was flat out awesome for them. Still had a couple stinkers, but he legitimately only had 1 bad game vs 5 great games. His GSAA is 2nd to only Shesty in the playoffs right now. Gourde was Gourde and that line was a huge part of this win. Ther job was to match up against the top line more often than not and tread water. For the most part they did that... and then some. That was overall Seattle's top scoring line and while holding MacK and Rants down.
Now for the Avs:
The depth on this team is putrid. No other way to split it... the bottom 6 forwards and bottom 2 defensemen are just not capable of their roles. This cost the Avs dearly in this series. They simply couldn't even tread water in their matchups... which really gave Seattle the edge for 2 or 3 of the shifts. It also caused the top guys for the Avs to play WAY too much. The top forwards were all out of gas multiple times in this series... but last night's 3rd after the offsides goal just showed how little was left in the tank.
George... he wasn't flat out bad per se, but he was very far from good. He has a negative GSAA for the series. Of his 18 goals against, I legitimately think at least 5 were very savable... he saves even 2 or 3 of those and the Avs move on. People will point to .914 and say that is good enough... but goaltending is more than just an average over time. It is not letting in bad goals. It is holding momentum. It is keeping your team tied when facing a ton of pressure so they can actually play with a lead to start a game. It isn't a scarlet letter situation here, but he simply has to be better. Avs are locked into him for a couple more years. He needs a better showing in next year's playoffs.
Compher... well... he's still Compher. He did an admirable job during the season and held court as a 2C. Best season of his career by far. That said, pretty clear to see he isn't a 2C by playoff team standards. Avs gotta find a solution at center. I hope he gets paid, but I hope it isn't here.
Now the biggest positive of the series was Rantanen. He still did his disappearing act and his terrible game but score two goals thing... but he was the Avs' best player in this series by a pretty large gap. When the Avs needed something, he was the most consistent guy to bring it. I think he played really well over all.
Which brings me to MacKinnon. The stat sheet will show 7 points. The highlights will show his dancing and taking over some shifts. But I think he had a pretty bad series. Some games he was pretty invisible or he'd only have ~2 of those shifts. He got some luck on his production (and some bad luck on not producing too). When he was away from Rants and Makar though, he was pretty terrible. All 3 of them together on the ice resulted in a ~76% xGF. Just Mikko and MacK, ~54%. MacK away from them ~48%. That simply isn't good enough from him. He needs to be able to row the boat on his own if needed. That's why he's a superstar and paid like one. We know he can produce and we know he can step up in the playoffs. That doesn't change him laying an egg in this series.
With Makar I'm expecting some sort of injury news. If he's healthy and performed like he did (which honestly is still great, just below our standards)... that is real disappointing. He wasn't nearly as impactful as he normally is, so hopefully there is a reason.
Another positive though, Toews. I thought he was spectacular in this series. Great defense, activating well, moved the puck... just was great. Consistently the Avs' best defensemen. After a ho-hum season for him, this was good to see.
The two bigger defensive names (Byram and G) left were a real disappointment. G's playoff struggles continue. The book is clear at this point... he needs a cycle buster who can also move the puck next to him. If he doesn't have that, he's going to struggle in the playoffs. He'll struggle from time to time anyway even with that player, but it will mitigate some of it. Byram... some bright flash, but a lot of mistake prone and riverboat hockey. His worst game was with Makar out when the Avs needed him to step up. He also couldn't provide enough offensive spark through the series either. I know many want to push him next to Makar and move Toews... I think the Avs will take a step back if they do that. Byram would have to take a pretty massive leap for that pairing to be as effective.
The bottom 6 as a whole was complete trash. Those players have to hold court and provide energy. They didn't. Which shouldn't be surprising since they are filled with 4th liners or worse... many of them not physical or spark plug types. I don't really blame the players on this so much as the front office. If you're going to go the cheap route, you gotta find more impactful players.
EJ, JMFJ, and Manson... these guys are all done. I know the injury will come up with Manson, and being injured plays into it... he's just lost a few steps though. If you watched him 5 years ago in Anaheim, you'd see how much of shell of a player he really is now. Back then, he could not only keep up, but he was a better skater than most NHLers. Today, he's behind the play and falling further behind the play. It leads to penalties and gaps in coverage. His deal is an anchor. EJ and JMFJ... they are just old. Not necessarily their fault they suck, but time they are put out to pasture.
I'm also pretty frustrated with Bednar here. Seattle's gameplan isn't complicated, nor did it take Bednar for surprise (he stated this). He didn't adjust his gameplan against Seattle's forecheck at all. Nor did he do anything in coverage to help break the cycle. He stuck with his plan and felt his guys would out talent Seattle. That just never happened. There were adjustments to be made here that would have worked to lessen Seattle's pressure... he chose to rely on talent instead.
Lastly, Nuke was the straw... whatever happened and him not taking part after game 2 was really the end. Maybe not for this series, but for this season. Even making it to round 2 would have had the Avs' rolled by Dallas.