No one should be snarkily dismissive of anyone's opinions. And if you think all the arguments are illogical and Barrie is our best blueliner, then just ignore all those people making those arguments. If these arguments are truly wrong, then surely it's possible to prove it beyond any reasonable doubt and convince the vast majority of people that you're right, then just quote your key arguments any time you feel the need to prove it again.
I mean this literally happens every time. The large majority do want Barrie kept around. And we use the same very clear arguments as to why its dumb to trade him all the time
They just get ignored by that minority who believe trading Barrie is somehow a great idea towards winning a cup.