Until the expansion rules get clarified, I don't think it is worth getting too up in arms about. We don't know how players will progress/regress over the next two or three seasons. Barrie could blow out both knees Thursday and render this all pointless.
I agree, I don't understand why anyone would freak out right now. At WORSE, the Avs are a playoff team on the way to being SC contenders and they end up making a trade with the Seattle Sasquatch (* that's what I'm calling them) to take a particular player in exchange for a pick or a prospect. Much like many other teams did with Vegas...paying a late 1st to keep a group of guys together is not a huge price to pay, if it has to come to that.
If the expansion draft happens in 2020 :
Avs protection list:
1F - Mack
2F - Rants
3F - Landy
4F - Jost
Kerfoot - exposed
Compher - exposed
1D - EJ
2D - Barrie
3D - Zadorov
4D - Girard
D - Timmins (auto-protected 2 years pro)
D - Makar (auto-protected 2 years pro)
1G - Grubauer
This season is going to be really indicative of where the Avs are at, who they are going to pick in the draft (C or W) and how they are going to structure their team going forward. If Timmins gets all healed up and plays a bunch of games with the big club, depending on how he performs he could definitely give them something to think about in terms of the future components of our defense. I expect Makar to be signed and playing with the Avs this coming April (much like McAvoy did with the Bruins) as well. One way or another, by the end of this NHL season things should be a lot clearer.
I truly don't get how some people want to lump fans into different categories like if
I think Barrie is going to get traded at some point -
it does NOT mean that I think he sucks - it just means that I think he could be moved out to address a different need on this team all the while taking advantage of a team that didn't manage their cap well enough to keep their young stars. It could also allow the Avs to use a different protection strategy and not really expose much more than role players. This has been pretty obvious for a while now. If the expansion draft happens in 2021, it definitely changes things but I personally believe that the Seattle group is to do what's necessary to get it done for 2020.