I'm confused...were the Rangers fans in Binghamton buying the B-Senators gear?
Yes people buy the gear, lots of it, the Senators are not a rival of the Rangers, yes they are in the same conference, but they are not a natural rival like the Devils. I equate it to a Yankees/Red Sox rivalry, if a Red Sox minor league team moved here I would never wear Red Sox gear.
You should see our rink when Hartford comes to town, at least 50-60% Rangers gear in the stands. Bsens fans will actually wear their Ranger gear and root for the away team that night (I could never do that, but lots do). It just shows how much of a Ranger town this still is.
I believe there are factors as to why they'll keep the Devils name. The main one being the recent upgrades to the Arena. The Sens main color is red, the Devils are also red. We had new red seats installed a few years back, the scoreboard is red, the paint around the arena is red, it's just easier to keep a red theme. The Dusters colors I spoke of before are yellow and brown, so it would take a face-lift to make that work and that costs money. (the seats would stay, they are waaaaay too expensive to change just for a team color)
The Senators have been here for 15 years, people have adopted the Senators as a favorite NHL team or a second favorite team (like I have). They are the franchise that brought AHL hockey back to this area after the Rangers left here in the 90's, and they brought us a Calder Cup, so there is a natural affinity for the Sens organization. After 15 years the organization has firmly established itself here. All our junior teams are Senators, etc. It's going to be odd to change, and it's going to make it all that more difficult to welcome a natural rival of most people's favorite NHL team. Re-branding from Devils I feel would help ease that transition and sell a hell of a lot more gear.
Hockey fans in this town are very nostalgic, they love to talk about the good old days of the Dusters and Whalers. You will still see Dusters and Whalers jerseys at every game. The Sens did a handful of throwback nights where the team wore Whalers or Dusters jerseys and auctioned them off after, they went for top dollar. I paid a lot of $ for my Whalers game worn throwback. They are missing a golden opportunity in not calling this team the Dusters.