I agree with you & BondraTime that Guenther has the potential to be the better player, but in this lineup I see Pinto's style of play as helping Jarventie & L. Brown by bringing a little more physicality to that line. And with Guenther's skillset that should help Norris & Formenton be a much more offensive line too. Rather than look at individual skillsets, I like to look at line combinations to see which players compliment each other to create the most effective line combinations.
If Pinto plays with Formenton & Norris I expect that the offence wouldn't be as productive, but with Guenther it could be, therefore creating three very offensively gifted lines with a little bit of everything on each line. Also Guenther would also be much younger & Pinto a little older giving him a little more experience at that point. Anyway, there are a lot of good players on that team that can be rearranged in all kinds of different ways to create different lines for different situations & all could be quite good I would think. They all seem like they could be very good players for a future team.
- I also like Huckins & Grubbe in the 2021 draft who could eventually replace Paul & Kastelic to add a little more offence on that bottom six. The Sens would have to create some draft day magic to pick up those four guys in the next draft (Guenther, Schmidt, Huckins & Grubbe). They would need at least one more late 1st rd pick & maybe another 2nd to have the assets to do it.