I watched a bunch more tape from 2019 U17s, 2020 5N-U17s, and some SHL and KHL games from early this season. I'll call this my pre-season rankings. Emphasis went, as much as possible, to players I've had multiple viewings of.
1. Brandt Clarke - An all-round phenom reminiscent of a young Drew Doughty or Josh Morrissey.
2. Carson Lambos - Some question marks about decision-making, but massive offensive upside. Best attribute is his skating.
3. Kent Johnson - The most dynamic offensive player of the class from what I've seen so far.
4. Cole Sillinger - Probably never going to be an offensive juggernaut, but has all the tools of an elite two-way center. Best attributes are his shot and defensive stick.
5. Luke Hughes - Some high end skills and decent size. Seems to find ways to create offense for his team without putting himself at risk defensively.
6. Aatu Räty - Barkov, Laine, Kakko, Kotkaniemi, and many others had much better 17-year-old seasons. Now in his 18-year-old season and he's still not a Liiga regular. Starting to think the hype was exaggerated.
7. Owen Power - I still haven't really seen him play so can't say much, but seems like he could be a force.
8. Simon Edvinsson - 6'4, great skater, highly skilled. Big question marks on the defensive side.
9. Matthew Beniers - Was the most dynamic player on the U18 NTDP team when he was on his game. Not as consistent as Smilanic or Bordeleau.
10. Dylan Guenther - Has all the tools of a first line power forward. Best attributes are skating and shot.
11. Fyodor Svechkov - Not the most dynamic, but one of the cleverest and most skilled offensive players in the class. Best attributes are offensive instincts and hands in tight.
12. William Eklund - Prior to last game, he played 17+ minutes in three consecutive. Part of one of the best lines in SHL right now with Alex Holtz and former first rounder Jacob Josefsson.
13. Chaz Lucius - Smart, skilled, creative. More cerebral than dynamic.
14. Simon Robertsson - Sturdy kid with NHL size. Shows some good skills, but mainly he's a responsible, pro-translatable player.
15. Corson Ceulemans - Highly skilled offensive defenseman with NHL size.
16. Jesper Wallstedt - Looks like the real deal. Can he go higher than Askarov?
17. Daniil Lazutin - Bit of a power game mixed with some pretty good skills. Best attribute is creating offense around the net.
18. Zachary Bolduc - QMJHL rookie of the year has NHL size.
19. Fabian Lysell - One of the most purely skilled and dynamic players of the class, but I'm still weary about his pro translatability.
20. Artyom Grushnikov - Smart, responsible puck-moving defenseman. Best attribute is his first pass.
21. Mason McTavish - A bull on the ice at the junior level. Can he continue to impose his will physically at higher levels?
22. Samu Salminen - Probably not gonna be an offensive dynamo in the NHL, but his 19 in 11 so far this year is the fifth highest points per game ever by a U18 in Finland's junior league behind only Pulkkinen, Selanne, Terravainen and Mikko Koivu. Plus he has an NHL frame.
23. Sasha Pastujov - He could quite possibly supplant Lucius as the top draft-eligible forward for NTDP. He's more purely skilled I would say. Just not entirely sold on his hockey IQ yet.
24. Vsevolod Gaidamak - Good skills, but his hockey sense, vision and creativity are his bread and butter.
25. Brennan Othmann - The one OHL forward who really stood out at U17s, besides Wright.
26. Atte Lehikoinen - I'm captivated by his defensive ability. At 5N-U17s he was out every shifts against Russia's top line of Yurov-Gaidamak-Svechkov and he handled them well. Also seems like there could be offensive upside hiding behind his responsible shutdown game.
27. Isaac Belliveau - Haven't seen him play much, but the numbers are pretty impressive for a 17 year old rookie.
28. Oskar Olausson - Another late birthday Swedish forward emerging as a regular pro.
29. Daniil Chayka - Keeps things simple, pretty good size and skills.
30. Stanislav Svozil - He's been an Extraliga regular for more than a year now already. Looks like he's ranged somwhere between 14-18 mins in his past few games
31. Zachary L'Heureux
32. Prokhor Poltapov - Highly skilled, but he's looked much better in Europe than in the tight spaces of North American ice.