If we are looking at players trading up to get a player ranked in the 18-20 range, I wouldn't mind Reichel.. but my top choice, and my hope for getting a top line player on the Sharks in this draft, is Seth Jarvis. I know others have mentioned him before so I am not unique in this assessment, but he looks like a top 6 NHL player to me. If he falls in the 20s (not sure why he would) and the Sharks draft him I would almost be okay with the high pick lost in the Karlsson trade. I worry about drafting a player like Reichel because how often has a Sharks prospect significantly improved their offensive ability after their draft year?
IMO, Jarvis just looks liked another player in the mold of Marner or Barzal, who the Sharks are sorely lacking. I would much prefer a dynamic and fast offensive player vs. a great 2way player, as the Sharks desperately need elite skating and offensive talent up front.