Yeah I noticed that when I was looking at team cap space yesterday. They really can't do a shake up or even bring in new faces without moving at least one of Kessel, JJ, Maata, or Hornquist. Kessel is by far the most attractive out of that group, JJ is almost unmovable.
They can move JJ with retention. He's a veteran bottom D with intangibles. He moves well, but he's makes stupid mistakes. No different than any other bottom pairing D. If he was making league minimum, noone would bat an eye.
It's like Schenn if he had a big contract. He looks alright in the right role and system. He's just never going to live up to all the hype when he was younger or live up to the contract. JJ can still skate, and he has size and intangibles. Everyone hates their bottom pairing D. Especially when they're overpaid. But I bet GM's and coaches love him.
Maatta is in a similar boat. He's slow as molasses, but reads the play well. Sort of the opposite of JJ in that sense. Also a lot younger. Only takes one GM to see something in him.
The problem I see is that if you dump those guys at 50% even, you still have to replace them. So you end up paying $1-2M for a replacement, plus $2M retention. Moving them only saves the Pens $0-$1M.
I think Hornqvist would be hard to move without retention as well, but he's a guy GM's and coaches would love to add. And frees up more space.
Kessel isn't overpaid, but he's got a bigger cap hit for other teams to accommodate. Might have a difficult time.