So i've been looking at the leafs roster over and over again, trying to see how they could bolster the defensive core while still retaining a solid 3rd line centerman to shutdown the opposing team while producing some goals/assists..
First off I want to say that I think the leafs should not move Kadri/Gardiner Yet.. I think they need to run with what they have (farm included) to see if they can keep the puck out of the net while producing the type of points we all expect with the latest addition of Tavares..
Worst case (positive) scenario; The leafs are averaging 2-3 goal games throughout the season, but are also allowing 2-3 goals against per game.. What do they do? what options do they have after attempting numerous lineups, but the end result remains the same?.. 3rd period collapses or just squeaking in a win after leading 3-0, then a nail bitter 3rd resulting in a 3-2 victory.. or the OT 3-3 w/loss outcome?
I keep coming back to the same team that Toronto should trade with... and that team is the Florida Panthers..
specifically adding a top 4 defender with some serious experience/leadership.. I don't think that the leaf's should trade out an offensive defender for a defensive defender, but I do think they should swap out the same type of player for a more well rounded type of player.. And that's where i bring in the name Keith Yandle. Some might cringe at this and say "bloated contract! he's not worth that!! 6.5 Million per year isn't worth that!, but look at Jake Gardiner.. We are paying him 4.05 Million for the same production levels but lack that experience we desperately need on the back end.
My theory on a trade that would benefit both parties involved would be the following;
To Florida Panthers:
Jake Gardiner
Nazim Kadri
To Toronto Maple Leafs:
Keith Yandle
Jared McCann
Why do I like this trade? Jared McCann is a young well rounded player i believe is finally coming into his own but will never breach the 2nd line C roll. He is extremely mature for his age, he's big.. he stands up for his teammates and fights when needed.. He can definitely score, and he also loves to battle vs top players. He finished the season strong last year, posting the best (+/-) on the Panthers, and was given lots of PK opportunities.
Contract swap:
Nazim Kadri - 4.5 Million till 2021-2022
Jake Gardiner - 4.05 Million Till 2018-2019 (UFA release)
Keith Yandle - 6.35 Million Till 2022-2023 (6 Million in remaining bonus) (UFA release)
Jared McCann - 1.25 Million till 2019-2020
Both teams can negotiate other factors like additional picks/trades etc.. but this would be the main core to the trade..
me personally, I think it's a win win for both clubs.. The panthers acquire the firepower they need to put the puck in the back of the net, and they have the ability to juggle the centers currently and flip them on wings w/ kadri, while still retaining an offensive player like Jake Gardiner on defense..
The leafs acquire Keith Yandle who should be able to really contribute on the blueline and bring leadership and experience to a much needed group on the blueline, while acquiring a proper 3rd line centerman who has been build/trained for the role.
Contracts are basically a wash, we break even.. no harm no foul..
Let me know your thoughts..
Cheers,