... if the Comets make the playoffs, could guys like Gaudette, Demko, MacEwen and Scheen all return for the playoff action?
...
YYY----------EEE------------SSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
First add Brisebois to that list.
All that is necessary is for the Canucks to paper them down if they are on the Canucks roster at the paper deadline. ...
With the sudden rash of injuries there is a small chance that the minimum roster size could interfere with the Canucks' getting everyone papered back down. The potential problem comes from Article 16.4(b) of the Collective Bargaining Agreement which reads in part:
"Clubs are not permitted to Loan Players where the result of such Loan(s) would reduce the Club's Active Roster below eighteen (18) skaters and two (2) goaltenders. ..."
As of February 15 the Canucks, according to capfriendly.com, have a full active roster of 23 players. That roster includes Gaudette, MacEwen, Schenn, Brisebois and Mazanec. It does not include Edler, Tanev, Sutter, Baertschi, Dorsett or Demko, all of whom are on injured reserve.
If the trade deadline was today the Canucks could not paper Mazanec to the Comets (it would get them below two goalies) and could only paper three out of Gaudette, MacEwen, Schenn and Brisebois as papering down all four would get them below 18 skaters.
Demko's announced time line for his injury would have him back before the deadline and it is likely that at least one of Edler, Tanev, Sutter and Baertschi will be back. There are also ways to play with the roster size a bit. I'm no insider and have no experience whatsoever in massaging roster size under the CBA, but some possibilities include:
If Demko isn't ready to come off IRL they could recall Bachman to the Canucks, assign Mazanec to Utica, put Bachman on the IRL and then call Mazanec back up. That would cost the club the difference between Bachman's NHL and AHL pay prorated for the rest of the season. Note this would only work because the AHL, having a limit on game rosters but no limits on active rosters, doesn't need to have a provision for injured reserve.
The Canucks could get another slot to paper a skater down by doing with Olli Juolevi what I've suggested could be done with Richard Bachman.
Imo the best way to get another skater slot to paper someone to Utica would be to call up Sam Gagner on or before the trade deadline day and paper someone down to Utica. Then they could reassign Gagner to the Marlies and recall the papered down player from Utica (or if the coaches prefer just keep Gagner.) The Marlies would lose Gagner for the AHL playoffs and the Comets would have the possibility of playing the player papered down.
If they had a player on an NHL contract playing in the ECHL or sitting in the AHL pressbox unused in Utica they could temporarily call up the ECHL or pressbox player and get another slot to paper down. They'd gain the right to have the Comets play the player papered down in the AHL playoffs and lose the right to play the ECHL or pressbox player in the AHL playoffs. The problem with that is that I don't think the Canucks have anybody in Kalamazoo or in the pressbox in Utica to do that with.
If willing to spend a roster spot and some money they could claim a player on waivers and assign a player to be papered down to Utica. Then they could put the claimed player back on waivers (perhaps hoping to lose him) and recall the papered down player.
I don't think taking an injured player off the injured reserve list intending to put him back on after papering down another player works because to get a player off injured reserve a physician must certify the player "is not disabled and is able to perform his duties as an NHL Player, which duties include playing in NHL Games." (Collective Bargaining Agreement Exhibit 28-B.) Having a physician make that certification and then immediately certify the player as disabled isn't going to fly without the player suffering a fresh injury or fresh symptoms.
Some of you will likely be aware of ways of massaging an active roster that I haven't thought of. All this won't matter at all unless the Canucks have four or more skaters or a goalie on the injured reserve list at the trade deadline.